Saturday, March 22, 2025

PASSOVER QUESTIONS ANSWERED #1, #2, #3, #4, #5,, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10. #11,

1.  

DOES COLOSSIANS
2:16 abolish the
FEASTS of GOD?

by 
 Keith Hunt

     Many a man down through the ages - some famous, some not
famous and some infamous - have tried reading the Bible, but
ended up rejecting it as coming from an all powerful God. These
individuals were stunned by the Bibles seemingly contradictions.
"This book" they said, "can not possibly be inspired for it
contains dozens of contradictions." And at first glance they
would seem to be right. Some Biblical scholars on seeing this
predicament have written whole books to answer the sceptics
concerning these contradictions. These Biblical scholars knew
that Jesus had said, "The Scripture cannot he broken'."  God did
not contradict Himself in His word.  They knew that for every
seeming contradiction there had to be a logical and harmonious
answer.

     For those outside the "church" to be sceptical of how the
Bible is written is one thing, and we should expect to find this.
But it has never ceased to be of amazement to me when some
Biblical scholars, ministers and lay people also believe, by what
they say and write, that the Bible contradicts itself !  And what
is even worse - they seem to be quite happy with that belief and
make no attempt to untangle their mind.

     One of these seeming contradictions of the Bible concerns
verse 16 of Colossians chapter 2.

     It is said by the apostle Peter that one reason Jesus came
to this earth was to leave "us an example, that you should
follower His steps: Who did not sin" ( 1 Pet. 2: 21, 22 ). The
apostle John wrote, "He that says he abides in Him ought himself
also so to walk, even as He walked" (1 John 2:6).
     Now those verses are quite plain I think - it doesn't take a
degree in a theological school to understand them. All we have to
do is look in the four Gospels and see HOW Jesus lived - what HE
taught, commanded and observed - and follow after Him - walk as
He walked. But here's where the problems start for some. You see
most have thought that Paul was telling the Jews and Gentiles at
Colossae (in chap.2:16) through his letter that those old laws in
the Old Covenant about eating and drinking, the 7th day Sabbath,
the New Month days and the Feasts, were now ABOLISHED (no longer
had to keep them) when one became a Christian.
      Ahhhhhhhh, but didn't Peter say Christ came to set us an
example for us to follow? Jesus kept the "eating and drinking"
laws - He kept the weekly Sabbath - He kept the Feasts of
Leviticus 23. Jesus did not teach these things would no longer
need to be observed after His death. He said nothing
about.........abolishment of the things listed by Paul in verse
16.
     In fact the opposite is the case. Look at what He said in
Mat.5:17-20. He first tells His disciples NOT to think He has
come to abolish the law (first five books) then notice
one of His plain teachings in verse 19, "Whosoever therefore
shall break one of these least commandments, AND shall teach men
so (to break what they think is the least commandments) he shall
be called the least in the Kingdom of heaven (doesn't say he'll
be in the Kingdom), BUT whosoever shall do and teach them, the
same shall be called great in the Kingdom of heaven. FOR..."
notice this, verse 20, "For I say unto you, that except your
righteousness(see Ps.119:172) shall exceed the righteousness of
the scribes and Pharisees, you shall in no case enter into the
Kingdom of heaven." The scribes and Pharisees kept the laws of
Col.2:16 externally at least.

     So to many Paul contradicted Jesus - he taught differently
than Jesus - he changed the teachings of Jesus.  But is that
REALLY SO?

                   PAUL CONTRADICTS HIMSELF?

     Not only do some think that Paul contradicted Jesus but that
Paul contradicted Paul. He tells the Jewish/Gentile church at
Rome (according to many) that they can choose their own days to
keep holy to God, and the Lord will accept them - Rom.14.
Now surely some - even some Gentiles - would have chosen the 7th
day Sabbath and the feast of Pentecost or day of Trumpets, as
would have some Jewish Christians. Paul teaches it would seem to
many here - FREEDOM! Yet, to the Jews and Gentiles at Colossae he
calls them out and instructs them to not let people teach them to
observe the ways of eating and drinking, the weekly Sabbath, new
month days and Feasts. At least many claim Paul is teaching this
to the Colossians.

     With all this seeming to be, contradictory teachings of
Paul, what do we find in the book of Acts on how Paul LIVED and
the FEASTS he observed? Why we fined he kept the 7th day Sabbath
- he kept the Passover (but the NT way as instituted by Christ) -
he kept the feast of Pentecost.
     In fact Paul did nothing that his Jewish Pharisaical enemies
could accuse him in breaking the laws of God,  see Acts chapters
22 through 26.

     Some claim Paul was a Christian Jew and as such it was okay
for him to still keep his Jewish heritage by observing the
Sabbath and Feasts, but the Gentiles did not have to do this, or
they could observe the 1st day of the week and different
festivals other than those found in Leviticus 23.

     With this reasoning, let's ask some questions. A Jew that
accepts Jesus as the Messiah - does he stop keeping the 7th day
and start keeping the 1st day? Does he continue to keep the 7th
day because it is national heritage and also start observing the
1st day as the Christian Sabbath? Or does he not observe either
the 7th or 1st day but can choose another as Romans 14 would
suggest he can do, according to how some interpret this section
of scripture.
     
      Does the Gentile have to keep Sunday as the NT "Lord's day"
? If so - what then is Romans 14 teaching? Does God have the 7th
day for Jews and the 1st day for Gentiles?

     Does God have one set of Feasts for the Jewish Christians
and another set of Feasts for the Gentile Christians? What does a
person do if they are half Jew and half Gentile blood? And how
does Romans 14 apply to all this? Does God have different ways
of salvation for different people?

     It is not the purpose of this article to explain what Paul
is teaching in Romans 14 - I have another article which does that
- all I will say here is that the "days" of Romans 14 have
nothing to do with Sabbaths or Feasts of God as found in the Old
Testament.

     No Paul never contradicted himself either in what he taught
or practiced.

     Now let's get to what Paul was teaching the church in
Colossians chapter 2.

                     THE CONTEXT OF COL.2:16

     Even the mightily inspired apostle Peter had to admit that
some things Paul wrote were "...hard to be understood" and he
went on to say that those who were unlearned AND unstable did
wrest unto their own destruction (2 Pet.3:16). The reason why so
many have trouble with Paul's writings is because they will not
look at the context of verses like Col.2:16 and the context of
Paul's life as recorded in the book of Acts. Too many want
to isolate a statement by Paul from the verses around that
statement and from other words of his in other letters. They read
Paul with what we call "tunnel vision" or with blinders (like
some horses wear over their eyes when racing) over their eyes so
they do not see all Paul wrote.

     First, let's notice the basic spiritual condition that the
people to whom Paul was writing were in. They had faith in Christ
and love for all saints (chap.1 v.4). They had been alienated
from Christ by the way they had lived but were now reconciled
(v.21). Paul took pleasure in their order and steadfastness of
faith in Christ (chap.2:5). They had been baptized (v.11-12). And
their sins had been blotted out (v.13-14).

     Secondly, we need to see the apprehension and fear that Paul
held for them and WHY. Paul wanted them to have full assurance of
understanding(v.2). He was concerned about them being led astray
by men with enticing words (v.4). He wanted them to WALK
in the way of Jesus (we have seen Peter said to do the same -
Jesus kept the Sabbath and Feasts of Lev.23) - see v.6. Paul
warns them about men preaching deceit, wrong philosophies,
teachings of the world, and ideas of men - that were opposed to
Christ's teachings (v.8). He warns them against people who were
entrapped in worshipping the spirit world, teaching observance to
the physical, from man's commandments, and asceticism (v.18-23).
     He warns them about all this, the ways of the unconverted
and deceived religious world of various false dogmas.

     With that background we can now start to understand what
Paul is warning the Colossian church about. Here was a people who
had been taught the gospel, had been shown the way and teachings
of Jesus - they had come to recognize they were sinners in need
of forgiveness - they had accepted Christ as Messiah and Savior -
they had been baptized, had their sins and debt of death removed.
They were now walking after Christ - living as He lived -
practicing things as He practiced them. Then Paul gets word that
sinister evil men were trying to shake and destroy their faith
and walk with Jesus, by enticing them with many traditions,
philosophies, doctrines, commandments of men and asceticism.

     These men are falsely telling them about how they have had
contact with the spirit world. They are preaching to the
Colossians that they have the spiritual truths not Epaphras their
minister. These beguiling men are saying to those who will
listen, that to follow this Christ and walk as He walked is
foolishness, and that they have the correct traditions, customs,
worship and commandments.

     Try to put yourself in the picture. You were a part of a
false pagan or religious society - doing things contrary to the
ways of Christ. Along comes a minister of Jesus and expounds the
saving truth to you - and you see your sins - you see that what
you have been believing and practicing have been the
philosophies, traditions and commandments of MEN. You see you are
a sinner in need of forgiveness - you see Jesus is the savior
- you repent and are baptized - you start to live as He lived,
walk as He walked. Your former friends and philosophical leaders
see they no longer have any influence over you pertaining to your
spiritual life. They do not understand your new faith - they
think what you are now doing is crazy!! Then they make every
effort to entice you back into their world and their man made
concepts and traditions.

      SO IT WAS FOR THE CONVERTS TO CHRIST AT COLOSSAE!

     These converts to Jesus at Colossae had been in sin - but
now are forgiver by the death of Christ on the stake. They now
have repented or their old former way of life, and are now
walking as Jesus walked - they are obeying God's laws concerning
eating and drinking - they are keeping as Jesus kept, the
festivals that God says are "my feasts" (Lev.23:1). Many are now
observing the 7th day Sabbath as God commanded in the fourth of
His 10 commandments (Ex.20). These followers of Jesus now observe
the Jewish calendar and honor the new month days set by that
calendar, together with the yearly Festivals as outlined in the
books of Moses. Then after they start to live this way - the way
Christ lived - along came men trying to criticize, sit in
judgment, and govern them back into their man made, philosophies,
commandments and traditions.

     Paul admonishes the Colossian church, "Let no man therefore
judge you..."

     What does Paul mean by "no man"? Is he saying that their
minister should not guide and govern them into God's way and
truth? Does he mean that he Paul should not lead and guide them
into the truth of Christ? Does the body of Christ - the church -
have no leadership, guidance, or government among itself? Of
course it does! See 1 Cor. 5 and 6:1-8.
      Paul is telling the Colossian Christians that they should
let no man of these ENTICING, BEGUILING, vain, fleshly minded men
of the world govern or sit in judgment over them concerning the
way they now eat and drink, and the festivals they now observe.
No PART of this way of life is to be governed by the outside
people of this world who reject Christ, or who make up their own
rules of religion for their spirit worship of the unseen.

     The Colossians are not to be governed by the fleshly
unconverted minds of men in regards as to "...eating and
drinking(as the Greek is), in regards festivals, new months
or sabbaths." The day to day eating and drinking habits, the
yearly, monthly, and weekly festivals, that God's people follow
should not be influenced, determined or governed by the
philosophies, traditions, doctrines and commandments of men who
would entice them from walking in Christ Jesus.

     Now notice verse 17. Did Paul teach and believe the physical
laws of eating and drinking were "done away"? Did he believe the
Festivals, new month days, the weekly Sabbaths of God were "done
away"? 
     Look at what he says regarding these, "Which ARE" present
tense in the Greek - "Which ARE (not were) a shadow of things to
come..." 
     A shadow leads to the reality! A shadow of a man appearing
around a corner will lead you to the man. 
     So it is with all of God's yearly, monthly and weekly
festivals - they have GREAT MEANING about "things to come."

     The Passover lamb was slain on the 14th of Nisan - Jesus as
the reality of the shadow was slain on the Passover day as the
true Lamb of God. The Passover festival was a shadow of things to
come.
     The feast of Firstfruits(Pentecost) was a shadow of things
to come - the outpouring of God's Holy Spirit came on that
precise day (Acts 2). 
     The feast of Trumpets is a shadow of the coming last trump
when Jesus will return to earth. All the weekly, monthly, and
yearly festivals are a "shadow of things to come." They ARE,
presently, today, continually a constant reminder of the
wonderful plan of God for this earth and the people on it.

     If the Christian world had continued to observe God's
festivals they would not be in confusion today as to what is the
plan of Salvation that the Lord has for mankind.

                 ....BUT THE BODY OF CHRIST?

     This phrase of Paul's has also been misused, abused, and not
understood but by a few. It is claimed that Paul was telling the
Colossians that laws to do with eating and drinking, festivals
and sabbaths were not important - were "done away" - only
accepting Jesus as the Messiah and Savior was now important. Just
"give your heart to the Lord brother," just "come as you are,"
the law is "done away and it's only grace today" is what
many teach that Paul is basically saying here in verse 17. 
     Nothing could be further from the truth!

     In the inspired original Greek that the New Testament was
written in, the little word "is" can not be found - it is not
there. This phrase should read, "but the body of Christ"
and that puts a whole different light on this passage. The word
"but" is a connecting word, and what most miss is WHERE it is
connecting. It is connecting with the thought of verse 16 - the
phrase, "Let no man therefore judge you." Put these two phrases
together and you have Paul's complete thought and statement with
a parenthetical thought inbetween.

     So Paul's complete statement should be, "Let no man
therefore judge you(parenthetical thought)but the body of
Christ." The Greek contained no punctuation whatsoever. Today we
would write verses 16 and 17 like this, "Let no man therefore
judge you(in eating and drinking, or observance of a festival, or
new month, or sabbaths, which  are a shadow of things to come)but
the body of Christ."

     The "body of Christ" are the collective remembers of the
church. This can be seen from the following verses of scripture:
1 Cor.6 15; Rom.12:5; 1 Cor.12:12-27. It is the church of Jesus
Christ through the Holy Spirit and the Ministry that God has
established (Eph.4:11 12) that is to govern and guide the church
as a whole in matters of Christian living and observance of
Festivals, not those outside the church with their various ways
of a so-called spirituality, based upon "the way that seems right
unto man but which ends in death." 

     Certain individuals were endeavoring to get the followers of
Christ at Colossae into observing man made food and drink
commandments (i.e. touch not, taste not, handle not - give up
something during the Lent season. Or, do not eat fish on Friday)
as well as their festive traditions (i.e. pagan Easter, Xmas,
January lst and the Roman-Greek calendar), philosophical
teachings, humanism, bodily flagellation (they still walk on
their blood covered knees while reciting prayers to the altar, in
some parts of the world) and spirit (angel-demon) worship. They
wanted the Christians to give up following the physical and
festival laws of the Hebrew God and reject Jesus as the Savior
from sin. Paul tells the Colossian church to pay no attention to
these fleshly minded men, but to let the body of Christ - the
church - be their light and guardian over the things they were
NOW ALREADY practicing (in the way of eating, drinking, 
festivals and sabbaths) as they walked in Christ.

     Contrary to the popular teaching or Colossians 2:16 this
section of scripture is one of the greatest proofs in the New
Testament that the Jewish and Gentile converts to Christianity
continued to observe not only the physical laws of God, but also
the weekly Sabbath, the new month days(Hebrew calendar as
governed by the Jewish authorities) and the Festivals of the Lord
as outlined in Leviticus 23.

                       .............

Foot note

I've purposely stayed away from getting too technically
scholastic with the Greek in this presentation, while at the same
time bringing out what the Greek means. I do not believe
God's children need a degree in NT Greek to understand what Paul
is teaching in this part of his letter to the Colossae church. It
is really quite plain to see from the whole context. For those
who could desire a somewhat more technical presentation of this
passage I refer you to the scholastic book FROM SABBATH TO SUNDAY
by Dr. Samuele Bacchiocchi (4569 Lisa Lane, Berries Springs,
Michigan 49103 USA). Dr. Bacchiocchi has another way to explain
this section of Paul's letter. While I personally do not agree
with his explanation, it does still agree with the truth I have
presented here - namely that the Christians (Jews-Gentile) of the
first century A.D. continued to observe the Sabbath and Feasts of
God as established in the Old Testament.

One of the most technical study articles I've seen to date on
this section of Paul's writings is by Larry Waker. He basically
gives the same explanation as Dr. Bacchiocchi. His articles are
available on computer disk (ASCII text format) for a donation of
$2.50 from: Sharing Disks, c/o John Guffey, 9700 South Anderson
Road, Oklahoma City, OK 73165, USA.

                            ...................

                        Written May 1987

                                  by

                          Keith Hunt

All articles and studies by Keith Hunt may be copied, published,
e-mailed, and distributed as led by the Spirit.


2.

Chronology of Exodus 12 to 16

Throw away the Charts!

                    CHRONOLOGY OF THE ISRAELITE EXODUS 

                                                (Exodus 12 to 16)


                                                           by
          
                                                   Keith Hunt



     I have seen over the last number of decades a few pretty
fancy charts and outlines, from people trying to put together a
day by day CHRONOLOGY of the Israelites coming out of Egypt -
chapters of Exodus 12 through to 16.

     Such "chronologists" have spent HOURS and hours figuring it
all out. Most of them have been from the Churches that DO observe
the Festivals of Leviticus 23. They somehow want to "fit" the
Passover and Feast of Unleavened Bread, and some even Pentecost,
into this nice neat framework of dates and days, to give I guess,
more credence to those Festivals of the Lord.

     It has been a complete WASTE of time for them. They would
have been better to have spent their time on other studies, than
this chronology stuff about the chapters of Exodus 12 to 16. They
have been day dreaming, and doing back flips and juggling tricks,
to make those events of Exodus 12 to 16 "fit in" with their
ideas, that to them will add weight to the observance of the
Festivals of God.
     The FESTIVALS of the Lord DO NOT NEED SUCH jig-saw puzzles
of chronology to establish them as God's Festivals that should be
observed by His people today!!

     Such chronologers have MISSED the simple points of Exodus 12
to 16.

     Now, dear reader, you take out your Bible and read from
Exodus 12 through to 16:1.

     Have you seen it? It is pretty simple! 

     Exodus 12 is the Passover ON the 14th of the month, the
first month. The Israelites reach the wilderness of Sin, ON the
15TH DAY of the SECOND MONTH!

     WITHIN FOUR CHAPTERS we have covered ONE MONTH AND ONE DAY!!

     Now, go back and read through once more, very carefully,
noting the places the Israelites pitched their tents, to stay a
while. 
     Exodus 12:37 - They left Rameses and pitched at Succoth,
which is just a Hebrew word for "booth" or "tent."

     The next we are told is in chapter 13 and verse 20. They
moved from Succoth to Etham, by the edge of the wilderness.

     Then it's chapter 14 and verse one. They are to encamp
before Pihahiroth, over against Baalzephon; by it they were to
camp over against the sea.

     Pharaoh and his army are coming after them, is the rest of
chapter 14. The children of Israel do go through the Red sea by
NIGHT and in the morning watch, and when the morning is appearing
the Egyptians try to flee but are drowned in the Red sea.

     We are at chapter 15. We have singing and praises for God
and His mighty power. Moses brings the Israelites through and out
of the Red sea, and to the wilderness of Shur - verse 22. They go
THREE DAYS JOURNEY in the wilderness - verse 22. They get to
Marah, verse 23. They had no water. They come to Elim and there
is water, and they camp, verse 27.

     They pick up and come to "the wilderness of sin" which is
between Elim and Sinai - ON THE 15TH DAY OF THE **SECOND**
MONTH!!

     It should be pretty easy and plain to see that FROM THE 14TH
OF THE FIRST MONTH (PASSOVER DAY) - CHAPTER 12; RIGHT TO CHAPTER
16:1 IS ONE WHOLE MONTH PLUS ONE DAY!   

     Now, it has to be either they stopped in those places way
MORE than ONE day, or there were OTHER places they pitched their
tents that we are NOT TOLD ABOUT. Then I suppose it could be
possible it was BOTH!

FURTHER PROOF

     You want a little more to back up what we have just read?
Turn to Numbers 33 and you will find it.

     Look at verse 3. Ah, it tells us clearly the Israelites
DEPARTED FROM RAMESES on the 15TH OF THE FIRST MONTH!

     They moved from Rameses and pitch at Succoth - verse 5.

     They departed from Succoth and pitched at Etham, on the edge
of the wilderness - verse 6.

     They removed from Etham, and turned to Pihahiroth, and they
pitched at Migdol - verse 7.

     They departed from Pihahiroth, and PASSED THROUGH THE MIDST
OF THE SEA INTO THE WILDERNESS, AND WENT THREE DAYS JOURNEY IN
THE WILDERNESS OF ETHAM AND PITCH AT MIRAH - verse 8.

     They left Mirah and CAME UNTO ELIM, where there was water -
verse 9!


     They moved from Elim and encamped by the Red sea - verse 10.

     They removed from the Red sea and encamped in the wilderness
of Sin - verse 11.

     NOW THAT HAS BROUGHT US BACK AGAIN TO EXODUS 16:1.

     HOW SIMPLE IT IS!  FROM THE PASSOVER ON THE 14TH DAY OF THE
FIRST MONTH, TO THE DAY THEY ARRIVE IN THE WILDERNESS OF SIN,
TOOK ONE WHOLE MONTH AND ONE DAY! They got to the wilderness of
Sin, on the 15th day of the SECOND month - Exodus 16:1.

     We are told SO LITTLE, just about NOTHING, of the
"chronological" day times of this period of time - one month and
one day. We are told the Passover was on the 14th day of the
first month. We are told they left Rameses on the 15th day of the
first month. We are told they crossed the Red sea by night. We
are told they did a three day journey into the wilderness. 

     AND THAT IS IT FRIENDS!!

     It is NOT POSSIBLE - it was NEVER INTENDED by the Lord - for
us to KNOW THE EXACT DAYS OF LENGTH THEY PITCHED THEIR TENTS AT
ANY ONE OF THE LOCATIONS MENTIONED.

     If you want to say they only pitched at each location
mentioned to us, for only one night. Then ACCORDING TO NUMBERS
33, you get a total of SEVEN or EIGHT DAYS, to reaching the
wilderness of Sin! And that has to include a three days journey
into the wilderness mentioned to us. So you could extend it all
to 10 or 11 days, to reach the wilderness of Sin.

     BUT IT'S NOT POSSIBLE to figure it that way, as we see
CLEARLY from Exodus 16:1 that it took the Israelites ONE MONTH
AND ONE DAY (from the 14th of the first month to the 15th of the
second month) to reach the wilderness of Sin!

     THROW THE CHARTS AWAY, THROW THE DIAGRAMS AWAY FOLKS! It is
just not possible to figure the chronology of Exodus 12 through
to chapter 16:1.

     AND FURTHER - IT DOES NOT MATTER - THE FESTIVALS OF THE LORD
ARE NOT ESTABLISHED UPON CHRONOLOGY!

                            ...................

Written December 2007


3.

The NIGHT to be much Observed?

A Re-Look at the Scriptures

               A RE-LOOK AT "THE NIGHT TO BE MUCH OBSERVED"
                                                 EXODUS 12:42


                                                          by

                                                   Keith Hunt
                                               (December 2007)


     In the "old" Worldwide Church of God, under Herbert
Armstrong, we observed "the night to be much observed" at the
BEGINNING or evening of the 15th day of the first month - Abib or
Nisan.
     It was the "tradition" to first meet as a local congregation
and have an very fine evening meal and fellowship. It was done
that way in the 1960s. Later it was "groups" of brethren getting
together in different home, varying from year to year. 
     Now, the evening of the 15th, is the start of the FIRST holy
day of the SEVEN days of Unleavened Bread Feast. The reader is
asked to study all my studies on the nitty-gritty of the Passover
and Feast of Unleavened Bread. A long study, which should take a
fair good time, if you are reading all the Scriptures and
meditating on them all. But worth the while if you still have
questions about "days" "evenings" "14th" "15" "7" or "8" days for
Unleavened Bread, and many more questions. 
     In all those studies, I do not remember if I gave much
inquiry into the "night to be much observed." I guess it was not
an issue at the time with most people, so I gave little or no
time re-looking at it per se. I guess you could say I went along
with the "traditional" keeping of it from way way back as taught
in  the old WCG.

     A recent gentleman emailed be about it and has indeed got me
to re-investigate the matter.

     I must say I was some surprised at what I've found, trying
to revisit this passage without any pre-conceived ideas. It has
been truly said that, most wrong theological ideas come from a
wrong premise or pre-conceived ideas.
     We must always be willing to look at sections of Scripture
with a new and open mind, but as someone said, not so open that
your brains fall out.
     So with this study I've endeavored to do just that, with
also the CONTEXT in mind.

     Certainly the beginning chapters of Exodus 12 is the
Passover. The lamb kept until the 10th day. Then on the 14th day
they killed it in the evening. The Israelites were commanded to
do certain things with its blood, and how to eat the lamb. The
Lord was going to PASS OVER THEIR HOUSES THAT NIGHT of the 14th!
(verses 6-13).
     It was to be a MEMORIAL day - a Feast day (verse 14). It did
in Jewish history take a somewhat elaborate number of hours,
lasting until the morning hours. I have elaborated on that in
some of my studies. It was in Israel quite a full evening as at
it was practiced by Jesus and His disciples, and other Jewish
families also (celebrated with a few other families in small
groups in homes).

     Exodus 12:15 starts a brief explanation of the 7 day feast
of Unleavened Bread, through to verse 20.

     We are then taken back to the main topic of this section,
the Passover in verse 21 and forward. They were to remember to
teach their children the wonderful meaning of the Passover
(verses 26-27).

     At MIDNIGHT the Lord smote all the first-born in the land of
Egypt. Pharaoh rose up in the NIGHT. He called for Moses by NIGHT
told Moses that he and the children of Israel should RISE UP AND
BE GONE! The Egyptians wanted them out mighty fast! So the people
got going as fast as they could go with live stock, donkeys,
sheep and goats, and don't forget small children. Yes, they took
much "spoils" from the Egyptians also, I guess you could say
"back pay" for hard work, very hard work, over generations of
time (verses 31-36).

     I believe the verses 37-41 are INSET VERSES.  Verses you can
put in brackets as in fact and thought put within an overall
basic context - the CONTEXT OF THE PASSOVER ON THE NIGHT OF THE
14TH OF THE FIRST MONTH.

     THEN YOU PICK UP THE CONTEXT AGAIN IN VERSE 42!

     IT IS A NIGHT TO BE MUCH OBSERVED UNTO THE LORD IN BRINGING
THEM OUT FROM THE LAND OF EGYPT. THIS IS THE NIGHT TO BE OBSERVED
OF ALL THE CHILDREN OF ISRAEL.

     WHAT NIGHT HAS BEEN THE CONTEXT NIGHT? WHY IT'S BEEN THE
NIGHT OF THE 14TH - THE NIGHT WHEN THE LORD PASSED-OVER THE
HOUSES - THOSE WITH THE BLOOD OF THE LAMB ON THE DOOR FRAME, WERE
SAVED BY THE BLOOD OF THE LAMB!

     PHARAOH RISES UP IN THE NIGHT AND TELLS MOSES AND AARON TO
"GET OUT OF HERE - BE GONE - TAKE OFF" AND DO IT FAST!

     AND ISRAEL DID EXACTLY THAT - THEY GOT MOVING TO RAMESES.

     AFTER VERSE 42, WHAT DO WE IMMEDIATELY FIND? GOD STARTS
TALKING ABOUT A CERTAIN IMPORTANT POINT OF HOW TO OBSERVE THE
PASSOVER - ALL THE WAY DOWN TO VERSE 49!

     THERE WAS ONE SPECIAL DAY - THE 14TH DAY - THE PASSOVER
EVENING/NIGHT OF THE 14TH AND THERE WAS A SPECIAL DAY OF THE
15TH, WHEN ISRAEL LEFT RAMESES UNDER FULL AND COMPLETE FREEDOM,
FREEDOM FROM THE MIDNIGHT OF THE 14 ACTUALLY, WHEN PHARAOH  GOT
UP IN THE NIGHT AND TOLD THEM TO "MOVE OUT, AND DO IT QUICKLY."

THE "NIGHT TO BE MUCH OBSERVED" OR AS THE MARGIN SAYS "A NIGHT OF
OBSERVATION" FROM THE **CONTEXT** IS THE NIGHT OF THE **14** -
NOT THE NIGHT OF THE 15TH!!

     In chapter 15 the day to REMEMBER in which God did a further
"bringing them out of Egypt" with a STRONG HAND was the 15th day,
when they LEFT RAMESES, AS they DID LEAVE Rameses on the 15th day
of the first month - see plainly what Numbers 33:3 says. Yes of
course they went out on that day from Rameses with a high hand in
the SIGHT of the Egyptians!

     Hence that beginning of the Feast of Unleavened Bread  was a
mighty walk out from Rameses. There could have well been 6
million, including children. Add to all that their cattle and
herds - it must have been some awesome sight in front of the
Egyptians, as they hopelessly beheld the departure of their once
slaved Israelites.

     So sure the beginning of chapter 13 pays attention to the
importance of the Feast of Unleavened Bread as Israel started to
march out of Rameses on the 15th. And in that context there is
NOTHING about leaving Rameses at NIGHT! If they depart on the
MORROW after the Passover, as they did, see Number 33:3; then
"morrow" after the Passover could have been after sunset, the
beginning of the 15th, a cool night travel for 3 or 4 hours. OR,
it could have been an early morning start on the 15th. Either
would be a moving out of Rameses on the 15th, the day AFTER the
Passover!


ONE MORE PASSAGE

     Turn to Deuteronomy 16:1.  "Observe the month of Abib, and
KEEP the PASSOVER....FOR IN THE MONTH OF ABIB THE LORD THY GOD
BROUGHT THEE FORTH OUT OF EGYPT BY NIGHT!"

     THE NEXT VERSE IMMEDIATELY TALKS ABOUT SACRIFICING THE
PASSOVER!

     WE AGAIN HAVE "NIGHT" CONNECTED WITH PASSOVER AND ISRAEL
COMING OUT OF EGYPT!

     IT SEEMS TO BE ADDING UP - AND TO MY THINKING THE WEIGHT OF
EVIDENCE IS IN FAVOUR OF THE PASSOVER NIGHT, THE BEGINNING OF THE
14TH OF ABIB, AS THAT VERY SPECIAL NIGHT TO BE OBSERVED!! AND NOT
THE 15TH PER SE. THE 15th IS IMPORTANT FOR IT IS A HOLY DAY.
     BUT LET'S FACE IT WHAT NIGHT AND DAY CAN COMPARE TO THE 14TH
OF NISAN? IT WAS THE NIGHT JESUS SPENT THE LAST PASSOVER ON EARTH
WITH HIS 12 DISCIPLES, AND INSTITUTED THE NEW TESTAMENT PASSOVER
ORDINANCES.

     NOW THIS IS REALLY A NIGHT TO BE OBSERVED. THIS IS A
MEMORIAL LIKE NO OTHER IN HISTORY - JESUS - GOD IN THE FLESH,
WILL DIE FOR THE SINS OF THE WORLD ON THIS VERY 14TH DAY, WHICH
STARTS WITH THE MEMORIAL PASSOVER EVENING!

     SURE THE DAY OF THE 15TH AND THEIR TRAVELS DURING THE FEAST
OF UNLEAVENED BREAD, TO MAKE THEIR WAY OUT OF THE PHYSICAL LAND
IS IMPORTANT, AND SO WE HAVE THE FEAST OF UNLEAVENED BREAD TO
COMMEMORATE THAT MARCH OUT OF SIN TO A NEW LIFE WITH GOD! 

     What about "this night being the night of bringing them out
from the land of the Egyptians"  (chap.12:42) - the Passover
night; And "Remember this day in which you came out of Egypt"
(chap.13:3) - the 15th day as they departed from Rameses.

     God often speaks at times AS IF it is a done deal. When He
decides to do a certain thing - IT WILL BE DONE, so He speaks
accordingly. When God had decided the time HAD COME for Israel to
leave Egypt, then when that death angel passed over at midnight
of the 14th, and Pharaoh made that call, and told Moses and
Israel to LEAVE, ALTHOUGH PHYSICALLY they were still, at that
point, IN THE LAND of Egypt, they had for all purposes and intent
LEFT EGYPT. GOD HAD FREED THEN FROM EGYPT! THEY TRULY WERE OUT OF
EGYPT, EVEN IF THEIR LEGS AND CATTLE HAD YET TO CROSS EGYPT'S
BOARDER LINE. 

     IT WOULD SEEM FROM THE LITTLE EVIDENCE GIVEN US THAT THE
NIGHT TO BE MUCH OBSERVED IS **NOT** THE BEGINNING OF THE 15TH
DAY OF ABIB, BUT THE VERY NIGHT OF THE 14TH - PASSOVER NIGHT!

     We certainly do not want to take anything away from the 15th
Holy Day of Abib - the first of the 7 complete days where only
un-leavened bread is to be eaten, but the night of the 14th is
the memorial of our Lord's sinless sacrifice for you and for me.

     SURELY INDEED THAT EVENING AND NIGHT IS TO BE MUCH OBSERVED!


                         ........................

Written December 2007

ADDED February 2010

First, the WCG and others were and are wrong in teaching the "night 
to be much ovserved" was the evening of the 15th. 

Now, specifically "even the self same day" - this phrase is
connected to the previous one "And it came to pass at the end of
the four hundred and thirty years...."
It is not written in the Bible per se (no chapter and verse)
about 430 years ealier of Israel "dwelling in Egypt" but from this 
statement we know GOD KNEW to the very day when the tribes of Israel 
CAME INTO Egypt, and 430 years later, to the exact day - the 14th 
of Nisan, Israel or "all the host of the Lord went out from the land 
of Egypt" - same verse. God inspired Moses to so record that God knew
the day Israel arrived in Egypt, and it was the same calendar day
that He was going to bring them freedom from Egypt, 430 years later
to the very same calendar day - context obviously is the 14th day.

Now, "going out from Egypt" WITHIN the CONTEXT is simply meaning
that that night of the 14th, when Pharaoh said "get out" - Israel
had been set free, they had "gone out of Egypt" but not yet
crossed the border line, but in true mental state they had left
Egypt, they were free people, no longer in Egypt as under their
domain, they were no longer slaves to the Egyptians.

This has to be the way to understand this "being free that night"
because EITHER WAY of the night of the 14th, OR the night of the
15th when they left Rameses (as we know other verses clearly tell
us they left Rameses on the 15th), they only marched on the 15th
to Succoth, which was not a town, but the word means "tent" or
"booths" - they moved for a while and then pitched their tens for
the night. So during the 14th day light they gathered at Rameses, and
did not leaves Rameses until the 15th. Either way then THEY STILL
HAD NOT left the physical land, had NOT crossed the border line
of Egypt, on the 14th OR 15th.
The phrase "went out from the land of Egypt" (which ever day, YOU
WANT TO PICK - 14th or 15th) MUST MEAN "they were free, no longer
slaves, no longer under the thumb or rulership of any Egypt
master, not even Pharaoh."

The phrase cannot be taken literally, as meaning they crossed the
border line of Egypt into another country on that day, for the
facts of the following chapters make it clear they DID NOT cross
the border line of Egypt either on the 14th or 15th day.
They did not leave the physical land of Egypt until they crossed
the Red Sea, and that was NOT done on EITHER the 14th or 15th day.

Hence there can be only one way to understand "went out from the
land of Egypt" and that is they were free, and they STARTED to
head for the border line. It is one of those phrases that must be
understood WITHIN the context it is written in. The context is
being slaves, under chains so to speak, of rulers, and then being
SET FREE! I think the slaves of the United States of America
could have used the very same phrase "I came out of the land
of the United States the day I was freed from slavery." Some did
literally leave, came to Canada, BUT NOT ON THAT DAY when they were 
given their freedom, and many stayed, but they had in 'spirit' been 
set free, had come out of the USA. Yet of course in this case the 
many who stayed willfully became part of the USA.

In Israel's case they all left (with others also going with them, 
as it is written) Egypt.
And the context shows, they were set free the night of the 14th.
God had told them to prepare to be set free with the Passover
meal, and then God set them free from Egypt through the death of the
firstborn in Egypt, and the command from Pharaoh to "get out of
here - be gone."


NOTE:

Some have tried to chronologize the events of Israel leaving
Egypt to have them going through the Red Sea on the last holy day
of the Feast of Unleavened Bread. It is simply NOT possible to so
figure! It is true the Israelites moved through the Red Sea at
night - see Exodus 14:20-31.
But if you take Numbers 33:1-10, noting especially verses 3-8 and
the places they pitched their tents before moving through the
midst of the sea into the wilderness, you cannot know for certain
what day they passed through the sea. If you only give one day
for each place mentioned, then it surely was NOT the last day of
the Feast of UB when they passed through the sea. 
We are not told HOW LONG they stayed at the places mentioned.
Giving each one day is human SPECULATION only.

It is NOT POSSIBLE to figure the daily chronology from Exodus 12
to 16:1. We are told the Passover was on the 14th day of the
first month and that getting to the wilderness of Sin, was on the
15th day of the second month. Anything else is PURELY up for
grabs. You could have a thousand chronologies from a thousand
different individuals and we still would not know which is the
right one. And it is not important to know, unless you have some
"pet" teaching you want to promulgate.

……………………………….. 


4.

WHY  DID  JESUS  NOT  DIE  AT  THE  TIME  OF  THYE  PASSOVER   EVENING   BEGINNING  OF  THE  14TH ?


I thought I needed to put this as an answer easy findable for people, for indeed many have this question.


Hi Keith


Hi Claire,


I have been reading your teachings with great interest an illumination.


***Glad you found my website.


I agree the last supper was on the beginning of the 14th.


***Yes it was.


But what I am struggling with is that Jesus had to die according to scripture. So would this not mean that he should have died on the eve of the 14th, when as you say the real Passover killing of the lambs took place.


***The Israelites had to eat the Passover at the beginning of the 14th as they were to leave Goshen in the morning of the 14th to Rameses and leave there the evening of the beginning of the 15th, Jesus  was the Passover lamb of the 14th; but no where was it ever said he had to die at the beginning of the 14th. It cannot be found in any prophecy

about his death that he had to die EXACTLY when the Passover lamb was killed and eaten.  It is like this: not all things regarding Christ as the Passover lamb was to be fulfilled EXACTLY the same, i.e. the Passover lamb was roasted by fire; Jesus was not burned at the stake, but hung on a cross; yes his blood was shed when he was speared in the side, cried out and died. So though he fulfilled the Passover lamb in type, not all "type" was done exactly, Jesus was not roasted at the stake as I've just pointed out.


He was to partake of his last Passover with his disciples so he could change the New Testament Passover to bread and fruit of the vine and foot-washing. Dying on the 14 was the main thing; the exact hour was not the main thing. It was unheard of that any Jew was put on a cross and died in the evening. The law of Moses said such had to be taken down before the new day began. That was why they came to brake the legs, so death would happen, but when they came to Jesus he was already dead.


All of this is on my website but there are many many Passover studies and it is all in one of them.


I know he still died on Passover but the way my brain works because it was 3pm on the 14th day, does this not mean he failed to fulfil scripture or is the time not important.

And if time was not important why was god so specific about the time in the OT.


***Because you must remember the time in the OT was connected with Israel leaving Egypt and the death angel passover over that night of the 14. So the Passover then was much more than just a type of the Passover lamb of God {Jesus} dying on the 14th. The original Passover was tied in with how God decided Israel would leave Egypt. As I've explained in many studies. It was just fine that Jesus died on the 14. Oh and it was not at 3 PM..... I have a study on that also. The first hour was 6 to 7. So work it out....you have an hour in which he died, we are not told what part of that hour he died. So even that proves the exact time on the 14 was not important, as long as it was on the 14.


I have searched for 3 days your teachings but can't find anything that answers this question.


***It's all there but there is so much it may take more than 3 days to find it all. Sure took me more than 3 days to study it all and write it all, about 3 years I would say :-)


In a few days I am due to fly to Uganda to preach do would very much appreciated getting this sorted as I don't want to preach anything other than the word.


***Hope it is now sorted out for you. all the best. Keith


P.S.  Not  all  parables  can  be  taken  to  full  face  value  so  to  speak;  they  often  break  down  at  some  points, i.e. the parable called "The Unjust Judge"  The  woman  pleads  with  the  judge   in  Luke  18:1-8.  It  is  obvious  the  unjust  judge  is  referring  to  God  the  Father   God  the  Father  is  never  "unjust."  The  main  point  is  something  else  in  the  parable … verse 7,8  is  the  main  point  of  the  parable.


…………………………………


5.

Seven Annual Sabbaths
Is It A Sin If You Do Not Keep Them?

                                    
    Those who tell us it is SIN to break the 7th day weekly
Sabbath will point to the fourth of the Ten Commandments in Ex.20
together with the verses of 1 Jn. 3:4 and Rom. 6:1 to show us
that being saved by GRACE does not mean we can continue to sin at
will.

    When these same individuals are asked about the 7 annual
Sabbaths God gave to Israel,and is it sin to not keep them as
sabbaths, many will say,  "no it is not sin to break them."  When
asked why they say this, an often reply is,  "The 7 annual
Sabbaths are not a part of the Ten Commandments, so we need not
keep them."  But is this reasoning of something not specifically
being a part of or not being stated in the Ten Commandments, a
valid argument ?

    God says to us,  "come let us reason together."  Let us be
willing to look at ALL of God's word and also use common logic.

    It is surely indeed true that the Ten Commandment law does
define what sin is ( 1 Jn 3:4; Rom.7:7 ). But, are the literal
words of these commandments the all complete - beginning and
ending, as to what is sin ? Or are they merely the basic
foundation upon which the whole gambit of sin and what
constitutes sin is built upon ?

    Surely even a casual reader of the Bible will come to see
very quickly that God expounds and amplifies throughout His word,
the meaning of sin - what constitutes sin, and various other
thoughts, attitudes and actions of life that are not specifically
worded in the Ten Commandments, but are nevertheless just as much
sin as those specifics of the TEN. Let me illustrate.

    Because of a general wrong heart in the Israelites who would
not look at the spirit and intent of the Ten Commandment law
( Deut.5:29 ) - God amplified for them those commandments with
many specifics.

    The commandment to honor father and mother for example, was
expanded to prohibit specific physical actions as well as a
general disobedient attitude - punishable by death.  "And  he
that smiteth his father, or his mother, shall be surely put to
death"  (Ex.21:15 ).   "And he that curses his father, or his
mother, shall be surely put to death"  (Ex..21:17 ).   
     "If a man have a stubborn and rebellious son, which will not
obey the voice of his father, or the voice of his mother, and
that when they chasten him, will not hearken unto them.......And
they shall say unto the elders of his city, This our son is
stubborn and rebellious, he will not obey our voice, he is a
glutton, and a drunkard. And all the men of his city shall stone
him with stones, that he die......." (Deut.21:18-21).
                                         
    The simple command to rest on the Sabbath wasn't sufficient
for a nation without the spirit and heart to obey God. In Exodus
16, the Israelites had to be told to stay at home after some went
out looking for manna on the Sabbath (v. 27-30 ). They had to be
instructed to keep the Sabbath in earing time and in harvest
(Ex.34:21 ). In Ex.35:2 3 fires were prohibited on the Sabbath.
Some commentators state that this prohibition referred only to
industrial fires used in the construction of the Tabernacle (see
the context of chapters 35-39 ). In any case, it is an example of
a more specific regulation being added to the broad general
commandment. The disregarding of this amplified instruction
regarding the Sabbath carried the death penalty (Num.15:32-36).

    The 8th command against stealing did not always carry a death
sentence, but one specific amplification of this command did, 
"And he that steals a man, and sells him, or if he be found
in his hand  (kidnapping ), he shall surely be put to death" 
(Ex.21:16 ).

    The command against murder was enlarged to include the death
sentence for anyone who knew his ox was wont to attack people,
but did not take protective measures and it had killed someone
(Ex. 21:29 ).

    The command against idolatry was expanded to include the
death sentence upon parents who sacrificed their children to
pagan gods (Lev. 20:2 ), upon witches (Ex. 22:18), upon wizards,
consulters with evil spirits, and those that used divination etc.
( Deut. 18:9-14 ).

    Adultery was punishable by death, but this law was enlarged
to include incest, homosexuality, lesbianism, bestiality (Lev.
20:10-17).

    We could go on and on showing how God amplified His Ten
Commandments in the first five books of the Bible, but the reader
can do this for him/her self.

    The point is this: the Ten Commandments are not the all in
all as to what is sin. They are the basic foundation and laconic
form from which many other laws of God are covered and taken.

    The Ten commandments can be divided into two sections - love
towards God (the first four) and love towards our neighbour (last
six).

    When Jesus was asked which was the greatest commandment, He
did not fall into the trap of naming any one specific law, but
said,   "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart,
and with all your life, and with all your mind. This is the first
and great commandment. And the second is like unto it. You shall
love your neighbour as yourself."  Jesus was not  doing away 
with any of God s commands.   He was just succinctly putting them
all under two basic headings, namely, love to God and love to
neighbour, for He finished His answer with,  "On these two
commandments hang ALL the law and the prophets"  (the entire Old
Testament - Mat.22:35 40 ).

    The TEN commandments are a concise form for ALL of God's
laws, and the commands, "love God with all your heart and love
your neighbour as yourself "  are an even more succinct
way to state all of the commandments of God.
                       
                         
           ANOTHER ARGUMENT ANSWERED - WHEN HOLY?
                                      

    It is argued:   The weekly Sabbath was made holy at creation 
from the beginning - the 7 annual Sabbaths were not.  And from
this reasoning it is taught we do not have to keep the annual
Sabbaths - it is not sin to break them. Is this using correct
understanding and logic?
     When we recognize WHO and WHAT is God, this argument falls
apart.

    God is the Eternal CREATOR of all that is visible and
invisible (Gen.1:1; Eph.1:12-16).He is HOLY character(Lev.19:2 ).
Wherever God IS in matter or time it becomes HOLY  (Ex.3:4,5;
20:8 11). God's presence in matter or time makes that matter or
time HOLY, whenever He chooses. For anyone to say God can not
make a period of time HOLY whenever He decides to make it holy,
has never yet come to understand who and what is God. Who is man
that he should reply to God,  "You only made the 7 annual
Sabbaths at Moses  time, so they are not holy or sabbath rest
days"  (cf.Rom.9:20 ).

    When God appeared to Moses out of the burning bush and told
him to take off his shoes because the ground he stood upon was
holy, it was holy at that time   not before - because God's
presence was now in that ground and as long as it was in that
ground IT WAS HOLY!!
     That piece of ground was not holy at creation but became
holy at Moses'  time - God making it holy by His presence in it.

    There is some evidence that God established His FESTIVALS
from the beginning, even ordaining them before He blessed and
sanctified the weekly 7th day sabbath, but even if that were not
so, He did bless and made holy 7 annual sabbaths at the time of
Moses - seven annual holy days that His presence was in and is
still in, for there is not one word from God in all His holy word
the Bible, to say He has since Christ or at the start of the New
Testament - abolished them. They are then still holy - still
sabbath days - and still sin to break them. The man made
arguments to abolish them by using Col.2:16; Eph.2:14,15 and
Rom.14 are answered elsewhere in our studies CHRISTIAN FESTIVALS
and LAW AND GRACE.

                          
                  SACRIFICES ON THE SABBATH


     Some people want to say that because annual sacrifices were
performed on the annual sabbaths and as there is no longer a
Levitical priesthood and a physical Temple in Jerusalem, as these
have been "done away with" so also have the annual Sabbaths.

     This is incorrect on at least TWO counts:
    
    1.   Ask the Jews if they agree with this reasoning.
    
    2.   Animal sacrifices by the Levitical priesthood were done
not only on the annual sabbaths, but on the weekly sabbaths and
on each day of the week (Num.28,29). If the ending of physical
animal sacrifices for this age "does away" with the annual
sabbaths, then it must by the same reasoning and logic, put an
end to the weekly sabbath and to all the days of the week.

    It is also worth noting that from Ex.12 we learn that God
gave Israel TWO of His annual sabbaths BEFORE revealing to them
which was the weekly sabbath (Ex.16), BEFORE the giving of the
Ten Commandments (Ex.20) and BEFORE the introduction of the
sacrificial system (Jer.7:22,23).

    Now it is time to see what is written in the law of God
regarding the weekly and annual SABBATHS.


                     THE WEEKLY SABBATH


    And on the seventh day God ended His work.....and He rested
on the seventh day.....and God blessed the seventh day and
sanctified  it..... (Gen.2:2-3).

    ......Tomorrow is the rest of the holy sabbath unto the
Lord.....for today is a sabbath unto the Lord.....So the people
rested on the seventh day (Ex.16:22-30).

    Remember the sabbath day to keep it holy.....But the seventh
day is the sabbath to the Lord your God.....Wherefore the Lord
blessed the sabbath day and hallowed it (Ex.20:8-11).

    You shall keep the sabbath therefore; for it is holy unto
you: every one that defiles it shall surely be put to
death.....Six days may work be done, but in the seventh is the
sabbath of rest, holy to the Lord.....the children of Israel
shall keep the sabbath, to observe the sabbath throughout their
generations, for a perpetual covenant (Ex.31:14-17).

    Six days shall work be done: but the seventh day is the
sabbath of rest, an holy convocation - you shall do no work - it
is the sabbath of the Lord in all your dwellings (Lev.23:3).


                      7 ANNUAL SABBATHS


    And God said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the
heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for
signs, and for festivals (seasons - Hebrew same as translated
"festivals" in other places), and for days, and years (Gen.1:14).

    Seven days shall you eat unleavened bread.....And in the
first day there shall be an holy convocation, and in the seventh
day there shall be an holy assembly to you, no manner of work
shall be done in them, save that which every man must eat, that
only may be done of you (Ex.12:15, 16).

    In the first day you shall have a holy convocation - you
shall do no servile work therein.....In the seventh day is an
holy convocation - you shall do no servile work (Lev.23:5-8;
Num.28:16-18, 25).

    Concerning Pentecost or First-fruits we read:  And you shall
proclaim on the selfsame day, that it may be a holy convocation
unto you - you shall do no servile work (Lev.23:15-16,21;
Num.28:26).

    In the seventh month, in the first day of the month, shall
you have a sabbath  - a memorial of blowing of trumpets, an holy
convocation. You shall do no servile work....(Lev.23:24,25;
Num.29:1).

    And it shall be a statute forever unto you: that in the
seventh month, on the tenth day shall you afflicy your souls, and
do no work at all.....It shall be a sabbath of rest unto
you.....(Lev.16:29-34).

    Also on the tenth day of this seventh month there shall be a
day of atonement. It shall be a holy convocation unto you.....And
you shall do no work in that same day.....And whatsoever soul it
be that does any work in that same day, that same soul will I
destroy from among his people. You shall do no manner of
work.....It shall be unto you a sabbath of rest (Lev.23:26-32).

    The fifteenth day of this seventh month shall be the feast of
Tabernacles for seven days unto the Lord. On the first day shall
be an holy convocation - you shall do no servile work.....on
the eighth day shall be an holy convocation unto you.....it is a
solem assembly - you shall do no servile work.....on the first
day shall be a sabbath, and on the eighth day shall be a
sabbath....(Lev.23:34-39; Num.29:12, 33).   


             ANNAUL SABBATHS - ARE THEY HOLY?                    


    Even with all the above evidence and words of the Lord
concerning His weekly and annual sabbaths, some will still argue
that somehow the annual sabbaths are not really holy sabbaths,
not holy as was and as is the weekly sabbath (if they still
believe the weekly 7th day sabbath is still holy, which many that
once did have now discarded). They want to argue that the
word "holy" is not used with the annual sabbaths in the same
direct way it is used with the weekly sabbath.
    The answer to this clever but weak argument was anticipated
by the Lord, hence He inspired the priest Ezra to give the truth
of the matter.

    Please turn to the book of Nehemiah, read it for yourselves,
mark it well, never forget it, for the first day of the seventh
month, the day and feast of Trumpets, it is written:  "......This
day is HOLY unto the Lord your God......for this day is HOLY unto
our God...." (Neh.8:9,10).

     This section of Scripture, together with the ones quoted
above prove:  1) The annual sabbaths are Sabbaths.  2) The annual
sabbaths are Holy to the Lord.  3) No regular or servile work is
to be done on the annual sabbaths.  4) Like the weekly sabbath,
the annual sabbaths are holy convocations.


                A LOGICAL QUESTION ANSWERED


     It will be asked:  If we have not had this truth of God s
word and commands revealed to us, or if we do not know when these
seven annual sabbaths are on the calendar, if there are no Jews
around to give us this information. If we are in ignorance -
surely we are not sinning?
     Does pleading  "ignorance"  disqualify you from the penalty
of breaking man s laws? NO! But you may be dealt with in a more
merciful manner. If you are not aware of God's law against
stealing and you steal, are you then not a thief? If you are
ignorant of God's law against fornication and you have sexual
intercourse before marriage, are you then free from any guilt or
sin? If you are unaware God says that you should not be a liar,
and you lie, does that mean you have not lied? 
     Let us see what God's word teaches regarding IGNORANCE.
Notice the account of ABTIMELECH - the King of Gerar - Gen. 20:
1-18. Because Abraham had said that Sarah was his sister and not
his wife, Abimelech was going to take her as his wife. God
revealed in a dream to the king that Sarah was Abraham's wife
(v.2,3). King Abimelech was doing this in  the integrity of my
heart and innocence of my hands  (v.5). God acknowledged this was
so. He showed extra mercy on him because of this (v.6), but
notice - if Abimelech had touched her in sexual union he would  
even in ignorance, have sinned! For God said,".....I also
withheld you from sinning against me - therefore suffered I you
not to touch her."  
     When God introduced the sacrificial system to Israel under
Moses, one section covered sacrifices for IGNORANCE! You will
find this in Leviticus, chapter four. Note verses 2, 13, 22,
27, 28. Breaking ANY of the commandments of the Lord, even in
ignorance, is still SIN! That sin must still be covered by blood
(the blood of animals represented the shed blood of Jesus) -
the penalty of sin - death - still had to be atoned for. Sins
through ignorance were still sins, during the age from Adam to
Moses, and during the age from Moses to Jesus.   What about this
age then?
     Here is what Christ taught,  "Who then is that faithful and
wise steward, whom His Lord shall make ruler over His
household.....Blessed is that servant, whom His Lord when He
comes shall find so doing (see Mat.7:21-27)......And that servant
which knew his lord's will, and prepared not himself, neither did
according to his will, shall BE BEATEN with many stripes
(he's in real bad shape -  Heb.10:26 31). But he that KNEW NOT
(ignorant ), and did commit things worthy of stripes (being
ignorant did not mean he was guiltless), shall be beaten with few
stripes (the penalty is still there). For unto whomsoever much is
given, of him shall be much required: and to whom men have
committed much, of him they will ask the more"  (Luke 12:42-
48). 
     What a privilege to be granted to know the Lord's will - to
be given His truths. But with that knowledge comes responsibility
and the cross-roads of life. We then must CHOOSE - death on the
one hand - eternal life, and the first resurrection on the other.
To know to do  "according to His will"  and to do it not is to
DIE in the SECOND death (Rom.6:23; Rev.2:11; 20:6,14; 21:7,8).  
     For those not called in this life (Jn 6:37, 44, 63-65; 1
Cor.1:26) -  for those ignorant of sin - those who do not know
the commandments of God - for those whose sins have not yet been
covered by the blood of Christ - for those who have not been
granted repentance (Rom.2:4; 2 Tim.2:24-26 ) to the forgiveness
of sins. For them is more grace and mercy  shown. They shall
be raised in the SECOND resurrection - the JUDGMENT period of
Rev.20:11-13. Then God's books (the Bible ) will be opened to
them -  the book of life also. They will come to see what
sin IS. Most will repent - have their sins forgiven, covered by
the blood of Jesus - receive the Holy Spirit and enter the very
family of God for all eternity.

     How great and wonderful are the ways of the Lord and His
plan of salvation as shown to us through His 7 Annual Sabbaths. 

      They are indeed HOLY -  let's keep them that way.

…………………………………….


6.

 PASSOVER UNDERSTANDINGS
                        
                               EXODUS 12:18

                     DOES THE PASSOVER AND 7 DAYS OF 
                  UNLEAVENED BREAD ALL BEGIN AT THE SAME
                TIME, AT THE BEGINNING OF THE 14TH, AND SO
                WE THEN HAVE  ONE SPRING FEAST FOR 7 DAYS?



     If from Ex.12:18 we are to understand the Feast of
Unleavened Bread beginning at the beginning of the 14th of the
first month, and if verse six is telling us that the Passover was
to be slain and eaten at the beginning of the 14th of the first
month, that together with verse 16, would be stating a number of
things we have not understood before, namely:  1) The Spring
Feast is 7 days long and not 8.  2) The 14th day is a Sabbath
day.  3) The Passover day is the first Sabbath day of the feast
of Unleavened Bread.

     Understanding these verses this way, may seem correct within
Exodus chapter 12. But, the Bible contains other verses on the
same subject matter. These also we must take into account. We are
not to read the Bible with horse blinkers over our eyes, or just
ignoring other verses that shed light on the same subject.  When
we look at all the other sections of Scripture in the Old
Testament(OT) concerning the Passover day and feast of Unleavened
Bread, there are some large errors in believing the Passover day
and feast of Unleavened Bread(FoUB) are all one, both beginning
at the same time, at the beginning of the 14th.

     There are some sections of Scripture that are hard to
understand, at first glance. Peter was inspired to say that some
of the things Paul wrote were hard to understand, by the
unlearned that is, as he went on to say (2 Peter 3:15 and
context).  Sometimes we have to search the Scriptures (Acts 17),
study to show ourselves approved, rightly dividing(putting
together verse with verse) the word of truth (2 Tim.2:15), to
come to the truth of the matter on a specific subject.
     The above are a few keys to correctly understand the Bible. 
I have covered in other Passover studies, many other truths
concerning this Spring Feast.  I have proved in earlier studies
that "between the two evenings" - the phrase used in Exodus 12:6
as to when the Passover lamb was to be killed and then eaten,
MEANS, from letting just the Bible interpret itself, at DUSK, or
TWILIGHT - the BEGINNING OF THE 14TH DAY. 
     All of this I have covered fully before. Hence we clearly
and plainly see from Exodus 12:6 that the Passover lamb was slain
as the 14th day began, and the Passover meal was eaten as that
14th night moved on.  
     That was the FIRST Passover celebration, starting at DUSK,
at the beginning of the 14th day of the first month.  Then if we
turn to Lev.23:5 we find this truth once more reiterated. And
again the phrase "between the two evenings" is used.  The
Passover, which was the killing of the lamb to spread it's blood
upon the door posts (in Ex.12) so when God passed over THAT NIGHT
(Ex.12:12) those under the blood of the lamb would be saved from
death, that Passover is IN the 14th day, and at TWILIGHT of the
14th day.
     The Passover lamb has to do WITH THE 14TH DAY, and I have
proved in other studies on how God used NUMBERS in the Bible,
that the number 14 is the number for SALVATION - BEING SAVED!  It
is two times 7, the number used by God for PERFECTION or
COMPLETENESS (the Eternal completed His work and rested the 7th
day - Gen.2).  The number 14 is DOUBLE perfection, as if saying
completely perfect, or perfectly and completely saved - God
making sure it is double "perfect" if He saves anyone.
     
     Now, notice Lev.23:6,7.   

     "And ON the fifteenth day of the same month is the FEAST of
UNLEAVENED BREAD unto the Lord: seven days you must eat
unleavened bread. In the first day you shall have a holy
convocation: you shall do no servile work therein."

     Within THREE verses next to each other are TWO days
mentioned - the 14th and the 15th.  The Passover on one and the
feast of Unleavened Bread starts on the other. I submit this is
prettysimple to understand. 
     I submit to you that a grade school child could easily
figure this one out.  Something called the Passover is IN the
14th day, not before and not after, but IN the 14th day. Argue
all you like about WHEN in the 14th day, but the words clearly
say it is IN the 14th day.  Then ON the 15th day, not before, is
the feast called Unleavened Bread. Then the thought continues
with verse seven, that the FIRST day of this feast is a Sabbath
of rest from servile work.
     The 15th comes AFTER the 14th. On the 15th and for SEVEN
days is the feast of Unleavened Bread in which unleavened bread
is to be eaten.  Now ask your grade schooler to start counting
SEVEN DAYS, with the first day being the 15th. Ask them to
stop when they come to the seventh day count. They will stop
counting ON and including the 21st day.
     As the 15th day starts at the end of the 14th, when the 14th
finishes, which according to the beginning, from the beginning as
Christ often said ("....but from the beginning it was not so"
Mat.19 for one example) was the "evening" (days beginning and
ending in the evening, Genesis chapter one), was at dusk or
twilight,  the 15th was from dusk, evening to evening. So the
21st day was not over until the END of that day at dusk
or evening.
     I submit, these verses in Leviticus, are simple to follow. 
In the first month there is the Passover day, being the 14th,
followed by, starting with the 15th day, the feast of Unleavened
Bread, continuing for seven day, until the end of the 21st day.

     This makes a TOTAL of EIGHT DAYS, not seven!

     One of the keys to understanding the Bible and all its
doctrines, is to let the simple easy to understand verses tell
you what they are telling you, in a logical way, without any
fancy foot interpretation.

     Let's look at one more simple logical couple of verses
concerning the Passover and feast of Unleavened Bread.  Turn to
Numbers 28, and just read verses 16 to 18.
     Again, it is IN the 14th day that the Passover is. And it is
IN the 15th day is the feast, the feast of seven days of
unleavened bread, and IN the first day (of this feast, the
logical continuation of the thought) is an holy convocation with
no servile work to be done.
     Now, with simple logic, if as some argue the Passover is at
the END of the 14th day, and if we go along with their argument
for verse 16, then the same logic and context of words for verse
15, means the feast is at the END of the 15th.  Yet, no one that
I know about who observe the feast of Unleavened Bread, start it
at the END of the 15th day.

     Once more in pretty clear language, the Passover is not
before or after the 14th but IN the 14th day, and the seven days
of Unleavened Bread feast, is not before the 14th but starts with
and in the 15th day.

     The word "passover" is found 48 times in the OT.  Only in
the two sections of Scripture we have looked at - Lev.23 and
Num.28 do we find the word used with fourteen and the feast on
the fifteenth. In other words only in these two places do we have
the simple and logical truth clearly laid out for us that the
Passover is IN the 14th day and the feast of Unleavened Bread is
IN the 15th day, and continues for seven days, the 15th day being
a Sabbath of rest from servile work.  In Exodus 12 and Lev.23 we
are also told that the seventh day of this feast is also a
Sabbath of no servile work.

     All of what I have just taken you through is very important
to our understanding of Exodus 12:18.  It is first of all a
letting of the easy Scriptures tell us in plain language 
what they say, meaning what they say and saying what they mean. 
When we have that as our foundation and rock to stand on, then we
may proceed to untangle the few harder verses that seem to say
something different.

     Now, as we read the Bible from cover to cover, there will be
some other things we will pick up on such as a BASIC NORM on
certain words and then now and again EXCEPTIONS to that norm.  We
need to remember that exceptions are just that - exceptions, to
the normal. They are not the norm or normal, but exceptions,
otherwise the exceptions would be the norm and the norm would be
the exceptions.

     We may ask: How or WHEN does God start the 24 hour day? Is
it at noon?  Is it at sunrise?  It is at 12 midnight?  Is it at 3
p.m. in the afternoon?  Going to the BEGINNING - the book of
Genesis and chapter one, we learn right off the bat, from the
beginning, that God STARTED days in the evening. Now that is the
NORM!  You can even look up the word "evening" in the Hebrew
lexicons, especially the larger and more detailed ones such as
"The Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament" and see that
from the Hebrew language, the norm is that days began in the
evening, at dusk or twilight.
     So, in the norm, a 24 hour day has only ONE evening, at the
very beginning of that 24 hour day.  
     Hence, when God was telling Israel about the day of
Atonement feast in Lev.23, He told them that they should
celebrate their Sabbath from EVEN(ing) to EVEN(ing). And
that Sabbath day of Atonement was the 10th day of the seventh
month.  The norm in God's mind is that days begin from evening
and last (the 24 hour day we are talking about, not the day light
part of a day) until the next evening, when a new day then
begins. The celebrating of Atonement feast was IN or ON the 10th
day, from evening to evening.
     The word "even" or "evening" is used dozens of times
throughout the Bible. In most cases it is just a part of speech,
such as saying, "and the evening had come."  Sometimes it is used
in conjunction with a number, like: "during the evening of the
third day" and no more is said.  In all such places it takes the
NORM, as first given to us in the beginning, the evening of the
day being the beginning of the day.
     That is letting the basic simple, first and MAIN meaning and
understanding of how the Bible uses "evening" interpret for us,
as we find this word in dozens of places.

     But, and here come the "but" with capital letters, BUT, from
time to time there are EXCEPTIONS, with capital letters for
emphasis, so you will remember this point.
     And as we are talking about the feast of Atonement in Lev.23
we shall stay there and see our first exception example.  

     Lev.23:26 tells us in clear language that it is the 10TH day
of the seventh month that is the day of Atonement.  Verse 32 says
it is a Sabbath of rest, then the last half of that verses says
we shall celebrate it FROM "even" to "even."  The NORM is that God starts days from evening to evening as we
see in Genesis chapter one. But there are times when God inspires
writers to use what to us has come to be known as the Roman way
to start and end days, from midnight to midnight.

When we understand this then all what might seem to be
contradictory is cleared up.

The evening of the 9th day, in this case, is indeed the evening that follows the
day light portion of the 9th day. And can so be called, in the
Roman way of counting days, the evening of the 9th day. At the
same time, in the norm of how God counts days, from evening to
evening, it is the start of the 10th day in this 7th month.

Within a relatively short passage of Scripture, God uses BOTH
ways to count days. He uses His way, hence the 10th day, and He
uses the Roman way, hence the feast of Atonement begins on the
evening of the 9th day, which is also the start of the 10th day
as we view it from the counting of days as found in Genesis
chapter one.

    The evening following the day light part of the 9th day is called 
here still the evening of the 9th day. It is the way we think of it
in our Roman way of counting days, from midnight to midnight. It is
the evening of the 9th day, but in the norm of God's recognizing it 
is the start of the 10th day. So God uses both ways of recognizing in
one sentence. It is the evening of the 9th in Roman counting of days,
but it is also the start of the 10th in the norm of Genesis chapter 
one.

     There are NORMS in the Bible for MANY things, but there are
also EXCEPTIONS to the norm at times.  Generally and normally,
the Spirit of God is given to a person under the New Covenant, at
BAPTISM, see Acts 2:38, BUT we find in the book of Acts
some EXCEPTIONS to that norm, the Spirit was given BEFORE
baptism! See Acts 10:44-48.
     
     We find in the New Testament, concerning "evening" an
EXCEPTION to the norm. Turn to the gospel of John, chapter 20. 
The context is clearly the FIRST DAY of the week. Also proved by
the rest of the gospel writers - Matthew, Mark and Luke as they
write concerning the same happenings.
     Notice, verse 19. Mark it well.  "Then the SAME DAY, at
EVENING, being the FIRST DAY of the week......"
     Here John, under inspiration by the Spirit, does the same as
the Eternal did in Lev.23:32.  He puts the evening that would
normally start the new day, or in this case, would have started
the SECOND day, as PART OF the same day of the context - the
FIRST day.
     Yes, there are now and then exceptions to the rule or the
norm.

     Now, with all the above firmly and clearly understood.
Knowing from the easy to understand verses we looked at in Lev.23
and Numbers 28 concerning the Passover in the 14th day and the
feast of Unleavened Bread in the 15th day, starting and
continuing for seven days, to the end of the 21st day.  Knowing
there are EIGHT days altogether from the 14th to the 21st - eight
days not seven. Knowing that the rule and norm for the evening of
a day to be the beginning of the day, but knowing the Bible does
use exceptions to that rule once in while.  Knowing we must take
the easy to understand verses on a subject, first, and let them
say what they say, and then in their light tackle the harder and
at first what may seem like contradictory verses.
     With all the above we are now ready to understand Exodus
12:18-20.

     Previous studies have proved from the Bible interpreting
itself, that "between the two evenings" and "even" of the 14th
day when the lambs were to be killed and the Passover eaten, was
the BEGINNING of the 14th, at DUSK or twilight. Hence verse 6 of
chapter 12, was at dusk, the beginning of the 14th day.  The
CONTEXT, right up to the end of verse 14 (interesting, verse 14
the context goes to) NEVER CHANGES. The Lord's Passover (verse
11) is IN the 14th day, not after it.  The Lord PASSED OVER
(Passover) "this night" (context is still 14th day) of the 14th
day (verses 12-13). This SAME DAY - the 14th - is a MEMORIAL (see
also 1 Cor.11 and the Greek for "in remembrance of me" - verse
24,25. It is "in THE remembrance/memorial of me." And Paul was
talking about the SAME NIGHT in which Jesus was betrayed, verse
23).
     Verse 14 of Exodus 12, calls the Passover a MEMORIAL and a
FEAST.
     God has SEVEN feasts and the Passover is ONE of those
feasts.

     Verse 15 of Exodus 12, STARTS a NEW thought and a set of new
commands and instructions. From verses 15 to 20 the context is
the Feast of Unleavened Bread.
     It is the same as Lev.23 and Numbers 28 we looked at, with a
few differences. It is SEVEN days in duration, the first of those
seven days is a holy convocation, a Sabbath of rest, no work
except that which may be for eating food. Exodus 12 tells us the
7th day of this FoUB is also an holy convocation, a Sabbath day. 
     We now come to verse 18.  The only way to understand this
verse, in the light of the plain simple verses on the subject of
starting and finishing this seven day feast, as given to us in
Lev.23 and Numbers 28, is that here we have an EXCEPTION to the
norm or rule, of the use of evening.  An exception such as found
in Lev.23:32 and John chapter 20.  
     The evening here in verse 18 would normally be the START of
the 15th day, but God chose to change the fast ball to a curve
ball for this pitch to home plate.  He can do this you know, as
He is God, He is the pitcher, the one delivering the goods, and
He can deliver as He chooses. God here chose to deliver with an
exception to the norm of speech that uses the word "even" or
"evening."  Here God chose to put the evening of the 15th AS PART
OF THE EVENING OF THE 14TH, THE EVENING HERE IS THE END OF THE
14TH, STARTING INTO THE 15TH DAY, GOING TO THE END OF OR
THE EVENING OF THE 21ST DAY, WHICH IS THE START OF THE 22ND DAY,
BUT PUT HERE AS STILL BELONGING TO THE 21ST DAY.  The same
principle as John saying Jesus came to them in the evening, being
the first day of the week. John putting the evening of the second
day (normally speaking as from the beginning - Gen.1) not with
the second day, but as part of the first day. The same principle
as God putting the day of Atonement in Lev.23:32 as from the
evening of the ninth day to the evening of the tenth day. An
exception to the norm, which usually as the rule of thumb, puts
the evening of a day at the beginning of the day, the start of a
new day, as from the beginning in Genesis chapter one.

     So, Exodus 12:18 DOES NOT CONTRADICT Lev.23:5-7 and Numbers
28:16-18, or the rest of the Scriptures proving the Passover was
at the beginning of the 14th, and the feast of Unleavened Bread
beginning on the 15th at dusk or evening, being a Sabbath day,
the first day of the seven day FoUB, lasting to the end of the
21st day, which was the last day, and a Sabbath day, to end this
Spring feast season, which consisted of TWO feast to the Lord,
the Passover memorial feast and the feast of seven days called
Unleavened Bread.

     All is in complete and perfect HARMONY when you believe the
simple and easy to understand verses FIRST, willing to search for
all verses on a subject, and then realize there may be an
EXCEPTION to the norm which then seems to be harder to understand
and even contradictory, but it is not, when you understand the
use of exceptions to the normal.

                      ..............................

All articles and studies by Keith Hunt may be copied, published,
e-mailed, and distributed as led by the Spirit. Mr.Hunt trusts
nothing will be changed without his consent.


7.

Easter/Passover Debate - Whitby 664 AD

The British Church did not observe Rome's Easter

               From the book "A History of the
                 English Church and People"

                                       by

                                     Bede


FOREWORD and added comments by Keith Hunt

The book by Bede is still in print and available through your
Bible Book Store. The "Introduction" by Leo Sherley-Price is most
revealing, as it admits that the practices of the British Church
were in many ways far different from that of Rome, yet in time
the Church of Rome dominated and all the "closer to the truth
practices" of the British church were finally extinguished in
those Isles we call Britain. A turning point in favor of the
Roman Church was the Synod of Whitby in 664 AD.

Bede recorded in his "History" the interesting debate that took
place. Here it is with my added comments throughout.



THE SYNOD OF WHITBY - 664 AD


King Oswy opened by observing that all who served the ONE God
should observe one rule of life, and since they all hoped for one
kingdom in heaven, they should not differ in celebrating the
sacraments of heaven. The synod now had the task of determining
which was the truer tradition, and this should be loyally
accepted by all. He then directed his own bishop Colman to speak
first, and to explain his own rite and its origin. Colman said:

     "Thee Easter customs which I observe were taught me by my
     superiors, who sent me here as a bishop; and all our
     forefathers, men beloved of God, are known to have observed
     these customs.  And lest anyone condemn or reject them as
     wrong, it is recorded that they owe their origin to the
     blessed evangelist Saint John, the disciple specially loved
     by our Lord, and all the churches
     over which he presided." 

(This is indeed what church history of the SECOND century also
tells us, in that Polycarp stated to the bishop of Rome, in
their debate over the time to observe our Lord's death, that he
was taught by John the apostle, who always observed it on the
14th of the first month in the Jewish calendar - Keith Hunt)

When he had concluded these and similar arguments, the king
directed Agilbert to explain the origin and authority of his own
customs. 
Agilbert replied: 

     "May I request that my disciple the priest Wilfrid be
     allowed to speak in my place? For we are both in full
     agreement with all those here present who support the
     traditions of our Church, and he can explain our view in the
     English language more competently and clearly than I can do
     through an interpreter."

When Wilfrid had received the king's command to speak, he said:  

     "Our Easter customs are those that we have
     seen universally served in Rome where the blessed Apostles
     Peter and Paul lived, taught, suffered, and are buried. We
     have also seen the same customs generally observed
     throughout Italy and Gaul when we travelled through these
     countries for study and prayer. Furthermore, we have learnt
     that Easter is observed by men of different nations and
     languages at one and the same time, in Africa, Asia, Egypt,
     Greece, and throughout the world wherever the Church of
     Christ has spread. The only people who stupidly contend
     against the whole world are these Scots and their partners
     in obstinacy the Picts and Britons, who inhabit a portion of
     these the two uttermost islands of the ocean."

(Of course Wilfrid was very correct here in stating that Easter
was observed in all parts of the world, where the Christian
Gospel had gone, for Easter was of great antiquity in the pagan
nations. A full study of Easter celebrations can be found on
this Website - Keith Hunt)

In reply to this statement, Colman answered: 

     "It is strange that you call us stupid when we uphold
     customs that rest on the authority of so great an Apostle,
     who was considered worthy to lean on our Lord's breast, and
     whose great wisdom is acknowledged throughout the world."

Wilfrid replied: 

     Far be it from us to charge John with stupidity, because he
     literally observed the Law of Moses at a time when the
     Church followed many Jewish practices, and the Apostles were
     not able immediately to abrogate the observances of the Law
     once given by God, lest they gave offence to believers who
     were Jews (whereas idols, on the other hand, being
     inventions of the Devil, must be renounced by all converts).
     For this reason Paul circumcised Timothy, offered sacrifice
     in the Temple, and shaved his head at Corinth with Aquila
     and Priscilla, for no other reason than that of avoiding
     offence to the Jews. For James said to Paul: 'Thou seest,
     brother, how many thousands of Jews there are which believe;
     and they are all zealous of the law.' But today, as the
     Gospel spreads throughout the world, it is unnecessary and
     indeed unlawful for the faithful to be circumcised or to
     offer animals to God in sacrifice. John, following the
     custom of the Law, used to be begin the Feast of Easter on
     the evening of the fourteenth day of the first month, not
     caring whether it fell on the Sabbath or on any other day.

(Interesting here to note Wilfrid knew that John observed the
Lord's death on the "evening" of the 14th day, yes, just as Jesus
did when He observed His last one with His disciples as recorded
in the Gospels. Also note that the same old argument that if you
do "anything" from the Law of Moses you do it to appease the Jews
only. Yes, it is the old argument from the early second century
that many of these "observances" were merely "ceremonial" and
"Jewish" while the NT Gospel did away with all them and
established new days and feasts to observe. It is the original RC
Church teaching - that they, with the Pope as the line of
succession from the apostle Peter, have the authority from God to
change "the times and seasons and laws" - Keith Hunt)


     But Peter, when he preached in Rome, remembering it was on
     the day after the Sabbath that our Lord rose from the dead
     and gave the world the hope of resurrection, realized that
     Easter should be kept as follows: like John, in accordance
     with the Law, he waited for moonrise on the evening of the
     fourteenth day of the first month. And if the Lord's Day,
     then called the morrow of the Sabbath, fell on the following
     day, he began to observe Easter the same evening, as we all
     do today. But, if the Lord's Day did not fall on the day
     following the fourteenth day of the moon, but on the
     sixteenth, seventeenth, or any other day up to the
     twenty-first, he waited until that day, and on the
     Sabbath evening preceding it he began the observance of the 

     Easter Festival. 

(This is of course utterly false and a plain lie from Wilfrid,
for there is NOTHING that even comes close to proving in all
recorded history in the Christian church and its writings, even
from the so-called "church fathers" that state the apostle Peter
ever practiced or taught such a things as what Wilfrid just
stated Peter did. In all my studies over the last 40 years in
Church History, I have never read anywhere, from anyone, that
Peter practiced such an observance of the Lord's death, or
Passover, or Easter, or what ever other name you want to call
that Spring Feasts - Keith Hunt)

     This evangelical and apostolical tradition does not abrogate
     but fulfil the Law, which ordained that the Passover be kept
     between the eve of the fourteenth and twenty-first days of
     the moon of that month.

(Again, Wilfrid tries to make out that Peter's observance of the
Lord's death could be anytime BETWEEN the 14th and 21st days of
the first month in the Jewish calendar. This is all very sloppy
Biblical scholarship. For the OT or law of Moses clearly states
the Passover is on the evening of the 14th and the Feast of
Unleavened Bread is from the beginning of the 15th to the end of
the 21st day of the first month. There was NOTHING in the OT to
state you could pick ANY day between the 14th and 21st to
celebrate the "Passover" or the Lord's death. But such do people
reason who think they have the weight of all the world - where
the RC Church had gone - to back them up. It becomes easy to make
up your own "theology" as you go along. It would seem Colman just
did not have the wisdom to see the gross error Wilfrid was
teaching, or he did not have the backbone to speak up LOUDLY
against such false Biblical understanding and show that the
apostle Peter would NEVER have developed such a practice as
Wilfrid was making out that Peter did - Keith Hunt)

     And this is the custom of all successors of blessed John in
     Asia since his death and is also that of the world-wide
     Church. This is the true and only Easter to be observed by
     the faithful. 

(Hummm....sounds like the "theology" that arose in another world-
wide church, under a man named Herbert W. Armstrong - a theology
that stated, "We are the only faithful, and I, as inspired of
God, as the leader of God's faithful, will tell you what to
practice, be it according to the Scriptures or not" - Keith Hunt)

     It was not newly decreed by the Council Nicaea, but
     reaffirmed by it, as Church history records.

(True per se, for Easter observance in the Roman Church began in
the early 2nd century, that is why Polycarp and Polycrates, who
came after Polycarp, went to Rome to debate the Easter/Passover
date issue with their respective bishops of Rome in their life
time - Polycarp and Polycrates were bishops in Asia Minor and
practiced what was taught to them by John the apostle - a 14th
day observance of the Lord's death on the in the first month of
the Jewish calendar - Keith Hunt)


     It is quite apparent, Colman, that you follow neither the
     example of John, as you imagine, nor that of Peter, whose
     tradition you deliberately contradict. Your keeping of
     Easter agrees neither with the Law nor with the Gospel. For
     John who kept Easter in  accordance with the decrees of
     Moses, did not keep to first day after the Sabbath; this is
     not your practice, for you keep Easter between the fifteenth
     and twenty-first days of the moon, you do not, for you keep
     it between fourteenth and twentieth days of the moon. As a
     result, you often begin Easter on the evening of the
     thirteenth day, which is not mentioned in the Law. Nor did
     our Lord, the Author and Giver of the Gospels, eat the old
     Passover or institute the Sacrament of the New Testament to
     be celebrated by the Church in memory of His Passion on that
     day, but on the fourteenth. 

(Here we begin to see some of the ERRORS of the then  British
church. Over the SIX centuries they had indeed fallen away into
some error on this issue and observance of our Savior's death.
When a people do this, be it by carelessness or by any other
means, the ones who are also in error have a readily made "crack
in the wall" to further their denunciation of what truth is
remaining by those who are somewhat closer to the truth, yet also
in error on parts of that truth - Keith Hunt) 

     Furthermore, when you keep Easter, you totally exclude the
     twenty-first day, which the Law of Moses particularly
     ordered to be observed. Therefore, I repeat, you follow
     neither John nor Peter, the Law nor the Gospel, in your
     keeping of our greatest Festival.

(And it was indeed true, the British Church had wandered from the
straight and narrow way, and had so fallen into error that made
their observance of the Passover or Lord's death, neither by the
standards of the Old or New Testament- Keith Hunt)

Colman in reply said:

     Do you maintain that Anatolius, a holy man highly spoken of
     in Church history, taught contrary to the Law and the
     Gospel, when he wrote that Easter should be kept between the
     fourteenth and twentieth days of the moon? Are we to believe
     that our most revered Father Columba and his successors, men
     so dear to God, thought or acted contrary to Holy Scripture
     when they followed this custom? The holiness of many of them
     is confirmed by heavenly signs, and their virtues by
     miracles; and having no doubt that they are Saints, I shall
     never cease to emulate their lives, customs, and discipline.

(Oh my, what a wrong mindset Colman had allowed himself and
others in the British Church to wander into. It is one of the
sure ways into error, even if you have a basic truth. God can use
and even show He is using and working with, men that are not all
infallible in their beliefs and customs, God allowing them to not
see all truth on all points of His word, in their life time. God
allows this, He reveals truth as He wills, sometimes it is for
other servants of His to find more truth on things that ones
before them did not find all truth on. To put yourself into the
mindset as what Colman had put himself into, is to surely trip up
and fall on your face as you basically try to hold to the faith
once delivered to the saints - Keith Hunt)

     It is well established that Anatolius was a most holy,
     learned, and praiseworthy man,answered Wilfrid; but how can
     you claim his authority when you do not follow his
     directions? For he followed the correct rule about Easter,
     and observed a cycle of nineteen years; but either you do
     not know of this general custom of the Christian Church, or
     else you ignore it. He calculated the fourteenth day of the
     moon at Easter according to the Egyptian method, counting it
     in the evening as the fifteenth day; similarly, he assigned
     the twentieth to Easter Sunday, regarding it after sunset as
     the twenty-first day. But it appears that you do not realize
     this distinction, since you sometimes keep Easter before
     full moon, that is, on the thirteenth day. And with regard
     to your Father Columba and his followers, whose holiness you
     claim to imitate and whose rules and customs you claim to
     have been supported by heavenly signs, I can only say that
     when many shall say to our Lord at the day of judgement:
     "Have we not prophesied in Thy name, and cast out devils,
     and done many wonderful works?" the Lord will reply, "I
     never knew you." Far be it from me to apply these words to
     your fathers; for it is more just to believe good rather
     than evil of those whom one does not know. So I do not deny
     that they were true servants of God and dear to Him, and
     that they loved Him in primitive simplicity but in devout
     sincerity. Nor do I think that their ways of keeping Easter
     were seriously harmful so long as no one came to show them a
     more perfect way to follow.   Indeed, I feel certain that,
     if any Catholic reckoner had come to them, they would
     readily have accepted his guidance, as we know that they
     readily observed such of God's ordinances as they already
     knew. 


(A great deal of "savvy" as we say used here by Wilfrid. He knew
the British Church had errors and mistakes in their observance of
when to observe the Lord's death. He could see the contradictions
in their "theological approach" to the issue, and with some
"kind" psychological charm, could make the debate swing
favourably in his Roman Catholic Church's direction to all those
listening to this debate. By using their weakest links Wilfrid
could then bring out the pomposity of the Church of Rome being
superior in Biblical understanding. Where truth is not fully
followed, or where there is no more "growing in grace and
knowledge" but only a looking to the outside of "men's lives" as
Colman had done towards some of his great men of God from the
past ages in his British Church, it is the surest way to destroy
what truth there might be remaining, as in this instance, for the
Church of Rome did finally succeed in implanting their observance
of Easter and Sunday all over the British Isles, over the next 3
or 4 centuries - Keith Hunt)

     But you and your colleagues are most certainly guilty of sin
     if you reject the indeed of the Apostolic See, indeed of the
     universal Church, which are confirmed by Holy Writ. For,
     although your Fathers were holy men, do you imagine that
     they, a few men in a corner of a remote island, are to be
     preferred before the universal Church of Christ throughout
     the world? And even if your Columba - or, may I say, ours
     also if he was the servant of Christ - was a Saint potent in
     miracles, can he take precedence before the most blessed
     Prince of the Apostles, to whom our Lord said: "Thou art
     Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church, and the
     gates of hell shall not prevail against it, and I will give
     unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven"?

(Now, Wilfrid thought it was the right time to bring in the upper
cut to the jaw of Colman. He now knew that Colman was not much of
a debater and did not have the understanding of the Scriptures to
cause any "come-back" with what he was now going to throw up to
him. He knew he could now hit him below the belt, with this final
discourse he hurdled out to him and everyone standing by - Keith
Hunt)

When Wilfrid had ended, the king asked: 

     Is it true, Colman, that these words were spoken to that
     Peter by our Lord?' 

He answered: 

     It is true, Your Majesty.

Then the king said: 

     Can you show that a similar authority was given to your
     Columba?

     No, replied Colman. 

     Do you both agree, (the king continued), that these words
     were indisputably addressed to Peter in the first place, and
     that our Lord gave him the keys of the kingdom of heaven?

Both answered 'We do.' 

At this, the king concluded: 

     Then, I tell you, Peter is guardian of the gates of heaven,
     and I shall not contradict him. I shall obey his commands in
     everything to the best of my knowledge and ability;
     otherwise, when I come to the gates of heaven, there may be
     no one to open them, because he who holds the keys has
     turned away.

When the king said this, all present, both high and low,
signified their agreement and, abandoning their imperfect
customs, hastened to adopt those which they had learned to be
better.

                              ..............

So it was, the part truth that the British Church had on
celebrating the death of our Lord Jesus, was mainly abandoned
from that day forward. It was to be another 500 years before the
7th day Sabbath of the British Church was finally extinguished
from Britain. Many small pockets of people in the hills and
valley of Wales and Scotland, held on to this truth, but the day
did come when the nation was fully drunk with the wine of the
spiritual fornication of the Woman who rode the beast (Revelation
17).

………………………………..

8.

                      PASSOVER
                   UNDERSTANDINGS
                
             THE TRUTH ABOUT 1 COR.5:7,8

                by Keith Hunt 




     The plain truth about certain verses of the Bible have not
been the exclusive right of understanding to just the leaders of
Sabbath observing Churches of God. Some well known scholars from
the Protestant world of Theology have also not only seen certain
truths of the Word of the Lord, but have had the courage to
proclaim them, write them, and even answer some arguments as they
did so.
     Such is the case with 1 Corinthians 5:7,8. What I am going
to give you in this study is from TWO well known scholars and
what has become a classic of a work, in their book called THE
LIFE AND EPISTLES of ST.PAUL.  The two scholars are W.J.
Conybeare, M.A. (Late Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge) and
J.S. Howson, D.D. (Dean of Chester). The above book is published
by Eerdmans Company, Grand Rapids, MI.  I do recommend this book
to all who want to seriously study the life of the apostle Paul.

     We shall begin their quote on page 381 as they introduce the
First Epistle to the Corinthians.

     " 1 The date of this Epistle can be fixed with more
precision than that of any other.
It gives us the means of ascertaining, not merely the year, but
even (with great probability) the month and week, in which it was
written.
     (1) Apollos had been working at Corinth, and was now with
St.Paul at Ephesus (1 Cor.1:12; 3:4, 22; 4:6; 16:12). This was
the case during St. Paul's residence at Ephesus (Acts 19:1).
     (2) He wrote during THE DAYS OF UNLEAVENED BREAD, i.e. at
Easter (1 Cor.5:7; see the note on that passage), and intended to
remain at Ephesus till Pentecost (16:8, cf.
15:32)...................."

     These two scholars could see from 1 Cor.5:7,8 that It was
during the Feast of Unleavened Bread that Paul wrote this letter
to the church at Corinth.
     Now we shall pick up their comments for those two above
verses in chapter five. All capitalization is mine.

     " In spite of the opinion of some eminent modern
commentators, which is countenanced by Chrysostom, WE MUST ADHERE
TO THE INTERPRETATION WHICH CONSIDERS THESE WORDS AS WRITTEN AT
THE PASCHAL SEASON, AND SUGGESTED BY IT. The words leaven, lump,
Paschal Lamb. and feast all AGREE NATURALLY WITH THIS VIEW. 

     It has been objected, that St. Paul would not address the
Corinthians as engaged in a feast which he, at Ephesus, was
celebrating; because it would be over before his letter could
reach them. Any one who has ever written a birthday letter to a
friend in India will see the weakness of this objection.

     It has also been urged that he would not address a mixed
church of Jews and gentiles as engaged in the celebration of a
Jewish feast. Those who urge this objection must have forgotten
that St. Paul addresses the Galatians (undoubtedly a mixed
church) as if they had all been formerly idolaters (Gal.4:8); and
addresses the romans, sometimes as if they were all Jews
(Rom.7:1), sometimes as if they were Gentiles (Rom.11:18). 

     It we take 'as ye are unleavened' in a METAPHORICAL sense,
it is SCARCELY CONSISTENT with the previous 'cast out the old
leaven' ;  for the passage would then amount to saying. ' Be free
from leaven (METAPHORICALLY) as you are free from leaven
(METAPHORICALLY)' ; whereas on the other view, St. Paul says, '
Be free from leaven (METAPHORICALLY) as you are free from leaven
(LITERALLY).'

     There seems no difficulty in supposing that the Gentile
Christians JOINED WITH the Jewish Christians IN CELEBRATING THE
PASCHAL FEAST AFTER THE JEWISH MANNER, AT LEAST TO THE EXTENT OF
ABSTAINING FROM LEAVEN IN THE LOVE-FEASTS. 
     AND WE SEE THAT ST. PAUL STILL OBSERVED THE 'DAYS OF
UNLEAVENED BREAD' AT THIS PERIOD OF HIS LIFE, FROM ACTS
20:6..............."

     Do you see the LOGIC and HONEST evaluation of those two
verses that these two men of Theology learning, were willing to
give and expound on this section a scripture. 

     Verse 8 is an admonition by Paul to effect a correct and
righteous attitude of mind and even certain literal church
disciplines that needed to be exercised, so the feast they
were observing could be kept with the unleavened bread of
sincerity and truth. As Christ was the true Passover Lamb of God,
as He had come and given Himself in sacrifice for sins, to put
away sin, to free them from the bondage of sin (Egypt) and
Pharaoh (Satan), and to lead them out of that bondage into the
Promised land of TRUTH and RIGHTEOUSNESS and the KINGDOM (Moses
being a type of Christ). Because of all that truth, they were to
put away the evil that was as leaven in the bread, that would if
not corrected eventually leaven with sin the whole lump of the
local church(verses 1-8).

     Here they were as the people of God, celebrating the
Passover and Unleavened Bread feast. They had the Passover
memorial service ALL MESSED UP, some getting drunk on the wine,
others making a huge meal out of it and not even sharing what
they had with those who had nothing, as we see from the
correction Paul gave them in chapter 11. And the feast of
Unleavened Bread?  Well instead of coming out of sin, they were
allowing INCEST to take place, and everyone knew it. They were
turning a blind eye to it, thinking that they were being KIND and
MERCIFUL. Even PROUD about not doing anything in the way of
discipline to the unrepentant sinner.
     Paul lays it on the line with them. He tells them there are
some things in the church that they are TO JUDGE. God will judge
those outside the church, but those open defiant sinners within
the church THEY are to judge, and the leaven was to be put away.
They were to observe the feast by putting open wickedness within
the congregation away, and  "Therefore LET US KEEP THE
FEAST........WITH THE UNLEAVENED  BREAD OF SINCERITY AND TRUTH."

     Those last words we shall look at in detail next time.

                    .......................

Written April 1997
by
Keith Hunt


                     PASSOVER
                  UNDERSTANDINGS
                
            THE TRUTH ABOUT 1 COR.5:7,8. continued


     Paul had written to the church at Corinth concerning what
action they should take in regards to a man practicing INCEST
within the very congregation. They all KNEW it was happening,
even took some pride in being kind and merciful to the man.
Probably thought if they took no action but showed how patient
they were towards him and his open sin, he would come to see he
should not be doing such evil, and withdraw from it all by
himself.
     Paul thought no such thing, and was very open to show them
their error on the matter. He told them he had judged the
situation as if he was right there with them. He told them that
with the power of Jesus Christ and in His very name, together
with Paul in spirit among them, they should disfellowship the
un-repentant sinner from their congregation(1 Cor.5:1-5).
     To glory in doing it any other way he told them was NOT
GOOD(verse 6). 

     It was the days of Unleavened Bread. They had put physical
leaven out of their homes. They were unleavened in that area and
sense of their lives. Now they were to get out the spiritual
UNleavened bread of open sin that was taking place among them,
and that would IF NOT CORRECT eventually spread like a cancer
until the whole was leavened with sin and wickedness. He reminds
them that Christ the Passover was sacrificed. That sacrifice was
not taken upon Himself so we could wilfully, casually, openly,
with a care free attitude, just sin to our hearts content, so
God's grace could be further magnified and glorified(Rom.6:1-6).
Christ did not come and die as the Passover Lamb so we could
continue in sin. He died to save us FROM sin, to put away sin, to
have us live not after sin but after righteousness. Yet here they
were allowing open un- repentant sin to be practiced within their
fellowship.

     The very feast they were observing was to teach them that
sin MUST BE PUT AWAY, CLEARED OUT OF OUR LIVES, AND TRUTH AND
SINCERITY WAS TO ENTER.
     Paul said to them: "Therefore(because Christ is our
Passover, and what that means) LET US KEEP THE FEAST........"
     The Greek TENSE for the words "let us keep" is FIRST PERSON,
PLURAL, PRESENT, SUBJUNCTIVE.  You can find this on page 148 of
the ANALYTICAL GREEK LEXICON.

     The FIRST PERSON PLURAL is readily seen in the words "let
us" - very personal and plural. He was telling them as a group of
persons, as Christians, THEY, US, should do something. They were
actually at the very time of his writing DOING SOMETHING. They
were observing the feast of the Passover and Days of Unleavened
Bread. They had put away physical leaven, now it was time for
THEM(plural) to put away the spiritual leaven of open sin.

     Then we have the PRESENT TENSE.  From the book ESSENTIALS OF
NEW TESTAMENT GREEK, Lesson three, page 11, by Summers, we read:
"The present tense indicates PROGRESSIVE action at the PRESENT
time - 'he is loosing' ........."

     They were at the time Paul was writing PROGRESSIVELY DOING
OR OBSERVING the feast of Unleavened Bread.

     Yet this PRESENT tense is also SUBJUNCTIVE.  This will take
a little more study and investigation, but the time and trouble
will pay off in fully understanding the thoughts and wishes of
Paul for the church at Corinth.

     Lesson 26 in the book ESSENTIALS OF NT GREEK, is called "The
Subjunctive Mood: Conditional Sentences.
     Page 105, under Grammatical Study we read:

     "(1) The forms of the subjunctive mood:
     Except for some very rare occurrences in the perfect tense
the subjunctive mood is used only in the present and the aorist
in New Testament Greek.................
     
     Page 106,107 under:
     (2) The function of the subjunctive mood:
     In grammatical study mood is defined as the affirmation of
the relation of action to reality. Is the action actually taking
place, or is it only potential?........the real and the
potential. In NT Greek there are FOUR TRUE mood; one expresses
real action (indicative), THREE express potential action
(subjunctive, optative, and imperative). IN OTHER WORDS, action
which is viewed by the speaker as real is expressed by the
indicative mood; action which is viewed by the speaker as
POSSIBLE,  contingent upon CERTAIN CONDITIONS, is expressed by
ONE of the POTENTIAL moods.......four English sentences
illustrate this principle:

     Indicative mood: THE CHILD RUNS. This expresses action which
is really taking place.
     Subjunctive mood: IF THE CHILD RUN, he will escape.  This
expresses action which is not really taking place but which is
objectively possible. The child has the ability to run. This of
all the potential moods is nearest to reality.
     Optative mood: OH, THAT THE CHILD WOULD RUN!.........one
step further away than the subjunctive.
     Imperative mood: RUN, CHILD..........It is the furthest
removed from the real action of the indicative mood..........."

     Let's stop there for a moment. Our phrase "let us keep" is
present progressive subjunctive. And subjunctive is action that
is objectively possible, contingent upon certain conditions. It
is the NEAREST to the actual reality of the thing in question(the
action) taking place.
     Now stop and think about the context of 1 Cor.5:7,8.  And
the very context of verse 8 itself. Paul WANTED THEM TO TAKE
ACTION AND PERFORM SOMETHING AS THE FEAST OF UNLEAVENED BREAD WAS
IN PROGRESS, AS THEY HAD UNLEAVENED THEMSELVES PHYSICALLY, THEY
SHOULD(ACTION) UNLEAVEN THEMSELVES SPIRITUALLY FROM SIN AND
WICKEDNESS(BY DOING A LITERAL ACT OF PUTTING AN UNREPENTANT OPEN
SINNER OUT OF THEIR FELLOWSHIP).

     Action then that was POTENTIAL UPON THEM MEETING CERTAIN
CONDITIONS. 
     IF THEY WOULD START TO KEEP THE FEAST WITH SINCERITY AND
TRUTH THEY WOULD PUT AWAY THE LEAVEN OF SIN(SPECIFICALLY THE MAN
PRACTICING INCEST). 

     Hold on to all that, we shall come back to it very shortly,
but I want to give a little more from lesson 26 of Summers' book.

     Page 108.

     "1. The HORTATORY subjunctive is the use of the FIRST PERSON
PLURAL to EXHORT OTHERS TO JOIN US IN AN ACTION......'Let us go
into the house.'............"

     Remember our phrase in the Greek "LET US KEEP" is in the
FIRST PERSON PLURAL, PRESENT. SUNJUNCTIVE.
     So first of all, Paul was EXHORTING OTHERS TO JOIN IN AN
ACTION WITH HIMSELF. He had already told them he had judged the
matter, and what they should do when they came together with him
there in spirit, was what he personally had judged - the sinner
was to be put out of their fellowship.
     In so doing they were being exhorted to CONTINUE
PROGRESSIVELY(present tense) to unleaven themselves spiritually
from sin and wickedness, as they had unleavened themselves
physically from leaven.

     Yet them doing this was SUBJUNCTIVE action they had NOT
REALLY YET actually done, but it was the closest to the reality.
Hence Paul did not use the Present Indicative mood(action
actually taking place), for they had not yet received his letter
that was exhorting them to take the action he was encouraging
them to take - disfellowship the open unrepentant sinner.
     
     Their action was not YET reality, but it was the closest to
it. It was action viewed by the speaker Paul as POSSIBLE,
contingent upon CERTAIN CONDITIONS.  To progressively(present
tense) continue keeping the feast of Unleavened Bread in the true
spirit of no leaven of wickedness, but the unleavened of
righteousness and truth, THEY would have to fulfil and meet the
conditions of putting away this blatant sinner from their
fellowship. 
     When that was done then the present SUBJUNCTIVE, would
become the present INDICATIVE - action on their part that was
literally and actually taking place.


     Let me once more try to put it all into simple English.


     Paul had received news about MANY problems the church at
Corinth was having. One was the problem of an open unrepentant
sinner practicing incest within their midst. He had heard they
were doing nothing about it, and even glorying in the mercy they
were showing this person by saying and doing nothing to correct
him.
     Paul did not agree with this kind of closed eye mercy or
favor. He had judged the matter very differently. He tells them
in his reply what they should be doing about this condition and
the Godly discipline they should exercise, by disfellowshipping
this man. As it was the feast of the days of Unleavened Bread, as
they had physically unleavened themselves in their homes, as they
knew that Christ was the Passover Lamb, and that He died to save
us FROM sin not IN our sins, not so we could continue to sin
freely and openly to our hearts content. 
     As it was the feast that pictured PUTTING AWAY SIN, the old
leaven of wickedness, and putting on the unleavened of truth and
holiness and right acting, he then EXHORTS them to do as he
would, to go forward in the progressiveness of the feast they
were celebrating, by taking the right action, based upon meeting
the conditions of demonstrating that right action, which was the
judging of this man to be such a sinner that it was needful to
put him out of their fellowship, until he had repented of his
malodorous, gross, unmistakable open sin of incest.

     What was the outcome to all this some may ask?  Ah, it was a
good outcome for EVERYONE in the end. We find in Paul's second
letter we have preserved for us ( 2 Corinthians) in the first
number of chapters, the answer.

     The church did take action, the correct discipline on this
matter. The sinner was put away from them, with much sorrow(for
such action by a congregation should never be a joy to do in one
sense). The sinner did in much grief come to heart felt
repentance over his practice. And Paul tells them  because of
these good results from this action, to re-instate the man back
to full brotherhood and fellowship (2 Cor.2:1-11, see such
translations as the Amplified Bible).

     Oh, what great lessons we are given in the word of the Lord
concerning His wonderful and meaningful FEASTS. What a BLESSING
they are!  What a GREAT PLAN of Salvation, Truth, Justice, Mercy,
and Love, are ours through the knowledge of the Feasts of the
Eternal.
     Let us never take them for granted, but let us REMEMBER
them. Let us MEDITATE upon them. Let us CONTINUE TO OBSERVE them
in SINCERITY AND IN TRUTH.

     In our next study we shall look at 1 Corinthians 11:20-34.

                 ..........................

Written April 1997
by
Keith Hunt


#9

Unusual Passover Observances!

The truth about the Samaritans/Passover

                            JEWISH FESTIVALS #3

                             History and Observance

                                            by

                                Hayyim schauss
                                        (1938)



UNUSUAL OBSERVANCES

Change of Emphasis

After the destruction of the second Temple, the custom of making
Pesach sacrifice was, of course, discarded. But Pesach did not
lose its status as a great national holiday. The celebration,
however, was exclusively in the home. In some places Jews still
partook of roasted meat on that night, exactly as they had done
before the destruction of the Temple, in certain places outside
of Jerusalem. But in general, only a reminder, a symbol of the
Pesach sacrifice, remained. It was customary in those days for
two main courses to be served at festive banquets of the rich,
and these two courses were served at the Pesach feast of every
Jew. But after the destruction of the second Temple, these two
courses were interpreted as reminders of the Pesach sacrifice and
the "chagigoh," the second or supplementary sacrifice. These two
courses usually consisted of a piece of roasted meat on the bone,
and a roasted egg.
     The holiday still remained for Jews the festival of
redemption. The freeing of Jerusalem from foreign rule became the
main item in the Messianic hope after the destruction of the city
by the Romans, and Rabbi Akiba therefore added a prayer to the
benediction for redemption in which was expressed the hope of the
Jew to live long enough to observe Pesach in a new, free
Jerusalem.
     Far from declining through the destruction of the Temple,
Pesach now attained still greater importance as the anniversary
of deliverance from the first and as the mdel for delivery from
the last exile.

     The ceremonial of Pesach eve was made even richer and
fuller. Jews would sit till late in the night, repeating and
discussing the story of the Exodus; often the coming of dawn
found them still gathered discussing the miracles of the
occasion. The plagues visited upon the Egyptians grew and grew
from the original ten to hundreds. The Jews spoke of Egypt but
they meant Rome. They spoke of the discomfiture of Pharaoh and
the Egyptians, hoping at the same time for the identical plagues
to be visited upon the Roman emperor, his governors, and his
soldiers, who had laid waste the holy city, destroyed the Temple,
and spilled oceans of Jewish blood
     In the main, the basic rite of the Pesach eve ceremonial
stayed the same as it had been in the days of the second Temple.
But the ritual for the evening became more set and formalized. In
the course of time various items of the ceremony were removed and
others added. We shall discuss this further when we speak of the
customs and ceremonials of Pesach. It is enough to say here that
the Jews of the Middle Ages celebrated the holiday almost as it
is observed by the Jews of today.

The Festival of Fear

     The ceremonial remained the same, but the attitude during
the Pesach festival changed in the latter part of the Middle
Ages. A new and evil force came from the outside and left its
imprint upon the old spring festival and observances, making of
it a time of fear for all Jews, a time of horrible visitations, a
time of terror and panic in the Jewish sections. At that time the
Church had the peoples of Europe completely under its control.
Fanatical priests and dark forces of reaction continually fanned
hatred against the Jews and spread the wildest charges against
them. The most horrible of these was the blood libel.

     The blood libel began to spread in the thirteenth century,
and countless numbers of Jews perished as a result. Due to the
ignorance and superstitious beliefs of the masses of those days,
the blood libel became bound up with Pesach, especially with the
Pesach eve ceremonial. It was charged that Jews killed Christian
children to get blood for the baking of matsos.
     Pesach was, therefore, a time of great fear for the Jews of
the Dark Ages. It was so easy to spread a rumor that Jews had
murdered a Christian child; there were many cases where some
individual enemy of the Jews would plant the body of a dead
Christian child in a Jewish home and give the signal for a raid
on the Jewish quarter on Pesach eve. Such an event is described
in Heine's historical romance, "The Rabbi of Bacharach."
     This superstition that Jews use Christian blood at Pesach is
not entirely a thing of the past. We, of this generation, have
memories of such charges in various European countries, and to
this day there are Jewish enemies who spread this accusation of
the Middle Ages in the very heart of Europe. (Remeber the author
is writing in 1938 - Keith Hunt)

     Even in America, only a few years ago, in Massena, New York,
the rabbi of the town was questioned on the blood ritual libel
when a little girl happened to disappear. The girl was found
unharmed the next day, and the mayor, the instigator of the
questioning, made a public apology.

The Marranos Observe It. 

     At the end of the European Middle Ages there was evolved a
notable method of observing Pesach among the Marranos, the secret
Jews of Spain and Portugal. These Marranos were entirely
separated from Jews and from Jewish life. They had no Jewish
books, and the only book on which they could draw for rules of
Jewish life was the Latin Bible of the Catholic Church. Basing
their ideas about Jews and Judaism on this one book, their
conception of Jewish life became an entirely false one. They
tried to live not as the Jews of their day did, but as the Jews
of the time of the Kings and the Prophets. They knew nothing of
the development of Pesach through the ages; they practiced the
Pesach described in the Bible.
     The question arises: How did these Marranos, who had no
Jewish calendars and no contacts with other Jews, know when to
observe the various Jewish festivals? Actually, they did not;
they reckoned the Jewish holidays by the calendar in general use,
applying the Jewish days to the secular month. Thus they observed
Yom Kippur on the tenth day after the New Moon of September and
Pesach at the full moon of March. When the spies of the
Inquisition discovered these observances, the Marranos of Spain
advanced the dates of the festivals, observing Yom Kippur on the
eleventh day following the New Moon of September and celebrating
the Seder (the ceremony of Pesach night) on a Pesach eve that
came sixteen days after the appearance of the New Moon of March,
instead of fourteen days.
     On this sixteenth day they would bake their matsos; on the
two preceding days which, according to their curious
Jewish-secular calendar, were really Pesach, they ate neither
bread nor matsos. There was no ceremony of the burning of the
chomets. Instead they burned a piece of the dough prepared for
the baking of the matsos. In the evening they observed a secret
Seder in their homes, eating an entire roast sheep, all the
participants wearing their traveling shoes and bearing staves in
their hands, exactly as described in the Bible. There were even
Marranos, those of Mexico, who followed the old biblical
injunction to smear the blood of the sheep on their doorposts.

     One noteworthy custom grew up among these Marranos: the
custom of beating the waters of a stream with willow branches,
which they interpreted as a reminder of the separating of the
waters of the Red Sea. It is interesting to note that to this
very day the Jews of Morocco make their way to a stream on the
last day of Pesach and there recite prayers and blessings. It is
possible that this was an old Spanish Jewish custom and that the
Marranos took it over and added to it the ceremony of the willow
branches which rightly belongs to Sukkos. That holiday they could
not observe at all, since one of the requirements of the festival
is to sit in booths in the open.
     The Pesach of the Marranos is not entirely a thing of the
past. There are, to this very day, Marranos in Portugal who still
observe Pesach in the manner just described.
(As this book was written in 1938 I have no idea if this way of
observing Passover is practiced by anyone today in 2010 as I
enter this - Keith Hunt)

The Samaritans and Falashas

     Marranos observed ancient forms of the Pesach ceremonial
because they were forcibly separated from the Jewish life of
their time and were forced to seek instructions from the books of
the Bible. External conditions forced the Marranos to return to a
primitive form of observance. There are, however, in our own day,
groups of Jews that never came in contact with the masses of the
Jewish folk; the never had anything to do with those Jews who are
the bearers of Jewish history and Jewish life. They, therefore,
observe Pesach exactly as it was observed two to three thousand
years ago. Such Jews are the Samaritans of the city of Nablus in
Palestine, and the a Falashas of Abyssinia.

***Modern historical research has proved that the Samaritans are
not descendants of the heathen colonists settled in the northern
kingdom of Israel by the conquerors of Samaria, as was once
assumed. Nor are they to be identified with Nehemiah's opponents
of the Persian period. Actually, the Samaritans of today are a
small and poor remnant of an old and great Jewish sect that
appeared in Palestine about the beginning „ of the Greek period.
They form the oldest Jewish sect in existence. They were always
strongly religious Jews who beieved in one God and strictly
observed the Law of Moses. The only religious books that they
possess, however  are the Pentateuch and Joshua. They never
recognized the books of the Bible beyond Josh as holy. Moreover,
they denied the sanctity of Jrusalem. They believed that Shechem,
the present Nablus, was the holy city and that the holy mountain
was not Zion, but Mount Gerizim. They built a temple on top of
that mountain, which was later destroyed by the Hasmonean king,
John Hyrcanus. The Samaritans and the Jews became blood-enemies
who hated and despised each other just as in later years the
Karaites and the Rabbinic Jews hated each other.***

(Please NOTE what was just stated by the author, read again
between the *** stars I entered for emphasis. The "Jewish
Encyclopedia" has a many page entry on the "Samaritans" - who
claim they are the descendants of the tribe of Ephraim. That
possibility could be true. It is quite possible that when the
House of Israel [in Samaria] was taken captive by the Assyrian
forces, SOME Israelites escaped, as is nearly always the case
when people are overrun by other people, and taken captive. What
is certain is that the Samaritans of Jesus' day and those of
today, were NOT pagan Gentiles that adopted some strange old
Samaria teachings and observances - Keith Hunt)


     In the days of the second Temple almost the entire central
part of Palestine, between Judah and Galilee, was thickly 
populated with this Jewish sect of Shechem; there were also many
followers of the sect in southern Syria and in other eastern
lands. Today, however, there are barely two hundred left; they
speak Arabic and inhabit a special quarter in Nablus. They have a
synagogue there and a High Priest, who is their teacher and
spiritual leader. (I have not done any research today in 2010 to
see if such Samaritan sect is still in existance, I guess a
search on Google would soon tell us - Keith Hunt)

     These two hundred Samaritans observe Pesach to this day (the
author was writing in 1938 - Keith Hunt) on Mount Gerizim, in a
manner that other Jews ceased practising thousands of years ago.
The custom of offering sacrifices has died out with the
Samaritans, except on the fourteenth day of Nisan, when they
offer the ceremonial Pesach sacrifice.

     Exactly as do other Jews, they clean the "chomets" out of
their homes the night before Pesach eve, according to their
calendar which closely resembles the Jewish. The next day they
make the pilgrimage to Mount Gerizim and there set up their
tents, one for each family, outfitting them with furniture and
utensils. There, on the slope of the hill on whose top once stood
their temple, they observe Pesach, living there for the entire
festival.

The Samaritan Practice

     A study of their ceremonies and observances during the
festival is of special interest to us, because they practically
duplicate the rites of the Jews of the very old days. What
certain knowledge we have of Pesach and its rites dates only from
the last century of the second Temple; of what happened before
there are no exact records. We can learn much about the holiday,
however, from the observances of the Samaritans of today; they
are for us a living record and monument of the old life lived by
the children of Israel on Mount of Ephraim.

     Much of the Pesach that was observed in the days of the
second Temple is still unknown to the present Samaritans. They
know nothing of the use of wine, of the "charoses," of eating the
sacrificial animal comfortably from a table, of reclining at
one's ease, and of many other observances, because these customs
came into Judaism in the latter part of the second Temple days,
after the Samaritans had already separated from the rest of
Jewry.

     The main ceremonial in the Pesach observance of the
Samaritans is the sacrifice of a sheep and eating it at night, in
great haste, together with matsos and bitter herbs. They begin
the preparation for the feast late in the afternoon. The Mount of
Gerizim becomes a center of activity. All the males of the sect
are gathered there, dressed in white, festive clothing, stoking
the fires in two huge pits, the one for the roasting of the
sheep, the other for the burning of the offal and all the remains
after the feast. A huge cauldron of hot water is also ready.
Half an hour before sunset the ceremony starts. The High Priest
leads the assembled congregation in silent prayer; the worshipers
fall to their knees, their faces toward the peak of the hill, the
spot where their temple once stood. The High Priest raises his
voice and all join him in a series of chanted prayers.

     Exactly at sunset (Note - it was sunset, not in the middle
of the afternoon; the Samaritans had retained the correct time of
the slaying of the lamb - Keith Hunt) the High Priest faces
westward and reads that portion of the Pentateuch which orders
the slaughtering of the Pesach sacrifice. About twelve or
fourteen of the younger Samaritans busy themselves, meanwhile,
with preparing the sacrificial animals. They form a circle about
the pit of fire, holding the lambs between their legs, and as the
High Priest utters the words, "And the whole assembly of the
congregation of Israel shall kill it at dusk," they utter a
benediction and throw the lambs, throats to the pit, where they
are slaughtered by two ritual slaughterers. Six or seven sheep
are slaughtered. An extra animal is available, should a physical
defect be found in one of the sacrificial animals.
     The slaughtering is a signal for general rejoicing.
Greetings are exchanged in the oriental manner; the participants
kiss one another, first on the right shoulder, then on the left.
     This ends the first part of the ceremony. The second part,
which takes place late at night, is the roasting of the animals.
     First, the bodies must be cleaned and spitted and prepared
for roasting. The fire made for the offal burns and smokes as the
insides of the animals are cast therein.
     At about ten o'clock the High Priest issues forth from his
tent and orders the roasting of the sheep. Six or seven men
bear the spitted animals on their shoulders and the High Priest
leads them in prayer; then all the sacrifices are cast into the
pit together. The bodies are covered first with leaves and grass
and then with caked mud. For three hours the roasting process
goes on, the Samaritans meanwhile passing the time in prayer or
in talk. Some go to sleep; but most of them rest on their cots,
for rest is needed so that the participants will feel fresh and
ready for the third part of the ceremony, the eating of the
sacrificed animals.

     At one in the morning all are awake and ready. Hands and
feet are washed and white garments donned. With girded loins and
with staves in their hands, they gather in one assemblage. The
roasted animals are in baskets and placed upon the earth. Matsos
and bitter herbs, that were gathered on the Mount, are placed on
the sheep and later portioned out by the High Priest. When all is
ready, the Samaritans form groups about the sacrificed animals
and, after uttering the prescribed blessing, fall upon the roast
meat, pulling it hastily to pieces with their hands. Portions are
brought to the women and children in the tents. Everybody eats
rapidly and in twenty minutes all that is left is a mound of
bones, which are thrown into the offal pit together with the
baskets and utensils that were used and with any matsos that
happen to be left. Matsoh is not prepared in advance for the
entire festival. The Samaritans bake a fresh supply every
morning.

(What we have been reading about the way the Samaritans observed
the Passover is near enough the way of the original Passover in
Exodus 12. It was just about an all night meal ceremony; the
killing, preparing, and roasting and eating of the lamb, would
take many hours. Hence in Exodus 12 THAT NIGHT was the "night to
be much observed" - for it was a special night, wherein the
Israelites would have stayed up all night. With such a meal,
taking many hours to perform, starting at sunset, the death angel
passing over at midnight to kill all the firstborn; with the
miracle and excitement of that night, except for small children,
it is inconceivable that anyone would have slept. This practice
by the Jewish sect of the Samaritans proves the time and night of
how the original Passover was observed - Keith Hunt)

     The burning of the remains does not, however, end the
ceremony. The Samaritans stay awake till dawn, reciting prayers.

(Again, showing that the original Passover of Exodus 12 was an
all night observance - no one was going to go to sleep on that
great and splended night when God would deliver Israel from the
bondage of Egyptian slavery. Truly a night to be much observed -
Keith Hunt)

Another Jewish Sect

     There is still another Jewish sect that makes the ceremonial
Pesach sacrifice: the black Jews, the Falashas, of Abyssinia. Who
these Falashas are we do not know for certain, nor do we know
what percentage of Jewish blood flows in their veins. There are
some who claim that the Falashas are Jews who intermingled with
the Africans. Others, however, contend that the Falashas are
African natives who, a long time ago, became converted to the
Jewish faith. Their Judaism is based on the laws and practices of
the Bible, which they read in an Ethiopian translation, and they
observe, therefore, only the old biblical holidays and festivals,
according to the laws laid down in the Pentateuch. They gather in
their synagogue on the fourteenth day of Nisan, before sundown,
and in the name of the entire community, an animal is sacrificed
and eaten according to the laws of the Bible, to the
accompaniment of chanted prayers. They also clean their homes of
"chomets" and prepare special dishes and utensils for Pesach.
 
Dramatic Presentations

     The Jews of the Caucasus region observe Pesach night sitting
on the ground, dressed in their festive best, with a spear and
sometimes a pistol by their sides. The women adorn themselves
with jewelry of all kinds and the young girls weave flowers in
their hair. The most interesting part of their Seder, however, is
the dramatic presentations acted there. These are introduced when
that part of the services is reached which states that in every
generation each Jew must feel as if he himself was redeemed from
Egypt. The Chacham (the rabbi), who leads the services, thereupon
wraps a piece of matsoh in an old cloth, places it upon his
shoulder and paces off four cubits, saying, "In this way our
forefathers went out of the land of Egypt, their
kneading-troughs, bound up in their clothes upon their
shoulders." He makes quick gestures at the same time to
demonstrate the haste with which the Jews left Egypt.
     The young men, meanwhile, go to another room and choose one
of their number to play the part of the fugitive Jew who has just
returned from Jerusalem bringing word that the redemption is
near. The others clothe him in rags, place a sack on his
shoulder, put a staff in his hand, and send him out. In a short
time a knock is heard at the door. There stands the masqueraded
youth, begging for permission to enter. The following
conversation takes place:

"Who are you and what do you want?"
"I am a Jew and I wish to observe Pesach, our time of
deliverance, with you."
"How are we to know that you are a Jew?"
"I wear a four-cornered garment with fringes." 
"Anybody can put one on. What other proof have you?" 
"I have not cut the corners of my hair. See my side-curls." 
"That is not enough, either. If you are a Jew, why do you travel
so late at night? Don't you know this is a festival?" 
"I come from Jerusalem, the holy city; the road is long and
filled with obstacles. Everywhere our enemies await us; like an
iron wall they stand between you and me in an effort to keep me
from celebrating the festival with you."

     The masquerader breaks into tears. Those in the household
still make no move to admit him. They remain silent and deep in
thought; occasionally one sighs deeply. Suddenly the leader of
the services gives a sign and the masquerader is admitted. He
stands amongst them with a sword by his side, a belt girt about
his loins, a staff in his hand, and a sack on his shoulders. His
sandals are roughly soled and his clothes are covered with dust.
The household suddenly becomes joyous and the masquerader is
showered with questions: 

"What is happening in Jerusalem, the holy city? How fare our
brothers? Is the Messiah coming soon to free us from exile? Have
any omens appeared pointing to our redemption?"

     The traveler tells them of Jerusalem, of the sages and
saints that live there, of the fields and villages that surround
the city, of the mountains and holy graves; and he assures his
listeners that the sages of the city have seen signs which point
to the coming of the Messiah, who will shatter the iron wall that
keeps them from entering the holy city. They listen with rapt
attention and at the conclusion they raise their hands high and,
sighing deeply, call out again and again, "Amen: So be His will."

     The Jews of Morocco are also fond of dramatization on Pesach
eve. After the reciting of the Seder services, every male in the
household slings a rod and pack over his shoulder. They rush out
of the house and run up and down the street, shouting, "In this
manner our forefathers went out of Egypt, their kneading-troughs
bound up in their clothes upon their shoulders."

     These Moroccan Jews carry away with them from the Seder a
piece of the "afikomon," the matsoh saved for the end of the
meal. They carry it as a safeguard on ocean voyages and throw it
into the waters in time of storm, claiming that it has powers to
calm the sea.
     The last day of the festival is visiting day. The
congregation makes its way to a stream on that day and offers
prayers. Toward evening the people go in groups from house to
house to say farewell to the holiday and to wish each other a
happy year. The day after Pesach they march outside the town and
recite blessings over the trees.     

                       .............................


INTERESTING INDEED! ESPECIALLY INTERESTING IS THAT ABOUT THE
JEWISH SECT OF THE SAMARITANS, AS THEY PRESERVED WHAT WAS CLOSE
TO THE ACTUAL PASSOVER NIGHT OF EXODUS 12.

Keith Hunt

March 2010


The Passover in Temple Times

Pharisee Traditions!

#10                                 THE JEWISH FESTIVALS #2

                                                        by

                                             Hayyim Schauss
                                                     (1938)



PASSOVER IN TEMPLE DAYS


Pilgrims in Jerusalem     

     At no time in its long and varied histoy was Jerusalem a
beautiful as in the years preceding the destruction of the second
Temple. In addition to the permanent dwellers, the three great
festivals would bring countless pilgrims from near and from far,
from every country to which Jews had wandered.
     It is estimated that Jerusalem, at that time, had a
permanent population of close to one hundred thousand and that
this was more than doubled by the pilgrims who came for the 
holidays, especially at Pesach.  No matter in what corner of the
world Jews lived, Jerusalem was a holy place to them, and the
greatest wish of each and every Jew was to enter the inner court
of the Temple at least once in his lifetime and to pray to God,
to the accompaniment of the holy music of the Levites. At no
other time of the year did so many pilgrims descend upon
Jerusalem as at the season of Pesach, when nature newly carpeted
the brown earth with green, and the fields of Judah seemed a
tapestry of flowers gleaming and glistening in the sun.
     Jerusalem was never so crowded as during the Pesach holiday.
Every inn was filled to overflowing, and whoever had a bit of
room in his house made it available to the visiting pilgrims,
never accepting any payment. It was customary, however, for the
pilgrims to offer their hosts the skins of the animals they had
sacrificed in the Temple. Many of the pilgrims set up tents in
the squares and open places of the town, living there during
their entire pilgrimage. Jerusalem was so crowded at this period
that the very fact that everybody was able to find accommodations
somehow, somewhere, was declared to be one of the miracles of
God.
     These thousands of pilgrims did not form a single,
homogeneous group; they were as varied as the world and as full
of color.
     There were Jews and Jewish converts from every country of
the known world, from Syria and Asia Minor, from Babylonia and
Medea, from Cyprus and Greece, and from Egypt and Rome. They did
not speak the same language; those from Mesopotamia and
thereabouts spoke various dialects of Aramaic; most of the Jews
who came from the west spoke Greek. There was, too, a great
difference in the outward appearance of these pilgrims. Side by
side one would see poor Jewish peasants who had traveled from
various districts of Palestine on donkeys, and rich Jewish
merchants or bankers that had arrived from distant lands by boat.
     All these pilgrims did not come to Jerusalem solely because
of pious motives. Many merchants arrived laden with wares, ready
to do business, for a holy city that attracted so many pilgrims
offered a fine opportunity for sale and barter. Jerusalem was a
ready market, even during ordinary times. There was always trade
in cattle and other live stock, which were needed for the
sacrifices, and in raw materials and finished products of all
kinds.
     Jerusalem was an especially fine sheep and cattle market
before Pesach, for so many animals were needed for the Pesach
sacrifices. There was also a large sale of the spices needed for
Pesach eve. Most of the cattle came from the immediate
neighborhood, but the spices were, in the main, imported from
Mesopotamia. Long camel trains from Mesopotamia, laden with
spices and herbs, were a common sight at this time of the
year. 

Preparations for Pesach

     Jerusalem is crowded with people and tumultous with their
noise. A steady succession of pilgrims pours into the town from
every side and through every gate.
     Further confusion is caused by the near-by peasants, driving
their cattle and sheep to market. The Roman Procurator has
already arrived from Caesaria, with additional soldiers to guard
against any possible uprising during that period. He is quartered
in Herod's Palace, which is more than a dwelling, being built
like a fortress, encircled by a high wall, studded with soaring
towers.
     It is early morning. The morning services has been completed
in the Temple and the worshipers have left the synagogues. The
market place, a broad street that stretches its way through the
entire town, is now filled with people. Both sides of the
thoroughfare are lined with booths, stands, and tables.
Everything is on sale here, whatever the eye can see or the heart
long for. Look! There are cakes made from wheat grown on Mount
Ephraim! And there, fish from the depths of Lake Kinnereth! A
third sells wine and a fourth calls to the passers-by to purchase
spices and condiments for the Pesach feast. Here is a booth
offering for sale jewelry and adornments which are the fashion in
Alexandria and Rome, and there is a street merchant offering a
syrup pressed from grapes. One dealer offers golden adornments
for the head, a specialty of the goldsmiths of Jerusalem, and he
calls, "Buy golden Jerusalems as a souvenir of the holy city." 
(a golden souvenir which the goldsmiths of Jerusalem sold to the
people)

     Not an inch of space is wasted. In front of the houses and
between the booths and stands sit tradesmen, using the street as
their workshop. A tailor sits cross-legged and sews fringes on a
coat; opposite him sits a shoemaker repairing the torn sandals of
a pilgrim; a blacksmith stands nearby, hammering away on the
handle of a sword.
     Each of the little side streets that lead off the market
street has its particular trade. There is the street of the
butchers and the street of the wool-combers; each little street
has its specialty. But the big street, the really interesting
street, is the great market place. Every moment it becomes more
crowded and noisy, and the scene becomes more varied and
exciting. The buyers, the sellers, and the idlers crush and
jostle each other for space. Here comes a group of pilgrims from
Alexandria, dressed in Grecian garments and speaking Greek to
each other. In contrast, a group of pilgrims from Galilee, very
pious Jewish peasants from the north of Palestine, follow them.
Their voices are heard high above the tumult of the market place,
and by the Galilean dialect of their Aramaic speech it is
recognized where they are from.
     Perhaps the greatest noise and the greatest crowds are in
the cattle market near the Mount of the Temple. Sheep and goats
are sold there by the thousands. Poor Jews bargain over the
prices of the animals; the richer pilgrims do not deign to
bargain and so pay higher prices for their sacrifical animals.
It is, however, not enough just to buy a sheep or goat in order
to be ready for Pesach eve. The sacrificial animal is not eaten
for one alone, but in groups that are made up in advance, for one
man cannot eat an entire animal and it is forbidden to leave any
part of the animal for the next day. So Jews rush about making
arrangements to form groups or to become part of one. A group
cannot consist of less than ten people, for it takes at least
that many to eat an entire sheep at one sitting. But some Jews
form huge groups, numbering so many that each member can get no
more than a mere taste of the sacrificial animal, a piece no
larger than an olive, entirely too small to satisfy one's hunger.
IT is customary, then, for such groups to slay another animal, an
additional festive offering called "chagigoh. This animal is
always useful. Unlike the official sacrifice, which had to be
eaten before dawn, the "chagigoh" may be held for a second day.

The Morning Before

     Thousands of priests and Levites are gathered in the  
Temple. There are twenty-four divisions of them on duty
throughout the land and, generally, there is only one
division present in Jerusalem to take care of the Temple service.
However, during the three great festivals, when there are so many
people in town and so many, to be sacrificed, all divisions come
to Jerusalem.

(What you are going to read now is the traditions of the
Pharisees, as they added to the word of Moses and even got the
wrong time to observe the eating of the Passover meal. The
correct observance is covered in detail in my studies on the
Passover on this Website - Keith Hunt)

     The "chomets," the bread and sour dough, is cleaned out of „
the houses. The night before, by the light of oil lamps, every,
corner is searched and every bit of "chomets" removed. All the
people in Jerusalem wait for the official signal to burn the
"chomets." This signal is given by the priests in the Temple who
use two disqualified loaves of the thanks offering. These loaves
are placed on top of the outside colonnade of the Temple. As long
as these two loaves are in view, "chomets" may still be eaten.
When one loaf is removed, the people cease eating "chomets." When
the second loaf is removed, then the people begin to burn their
"chomets."
     But this system of signals is not sufficient for all of
Jerusalem and another is arranged. Two kine are set to plowing
the earth on top of the Mount of Olives and as long as both are
attached to the plow, "chomets" may still be eaten. The
unhitching of one is a signal to cease eating "chomets" and the
removal of the second is a sign to burn "chomets."

(None of this tradition of course can be found in the books of
Moses. And the discription that follows is as the Pharisees
taught it on the daylight part of the 14th of Nisan - Keith Hunt)

Midday

     The spirit of the holiday has permeated every nook and canny
of Jerusalem. By now all have ceased working; even the tailors,
the shoemakers, the haircutters, and washers have finished the
last piece of work for the pilgrims.
     Thousands of Jews march through the town, this one with a
sheep, that one with a goat, riding high on his shoulder. All
direct their steps to the Temple, to be among the first to offer
their Pesach sacrifice. The regular afternoon sacrifice at the
Temple is offered an hour earlier than usual and at about three
o'clock the people begin the slaughtering of the Pesach
sacrifice.

     The ritual is repeated three times. When the court of the
Temple is filled with the first comers, the gates are shut. The
Levites blow the ceremonial "t'kioh, t'ruoh, t'kioh" (a threefold
blast) on their trumpets and the sacrifice begins. The owner
himself slays the animal. The priests stand in rows, bearing
aloft gold and silver trays, each metal borne by a different row
of priests.
     They perform their share of the ritual and the Levites stand
on a platform and sing "Hallel," Psalms of praise for holidays,
to the accompaniment of musical instruments. The elaborateness of
the ritual and the singing and playing of the Levites add dignity
and beauty to the scene, and the Jews gathered in the court are
filled with devotion and piety.
     The first section files out of the court and the second
section files in. The same ritual is performed again. It is
repeated once more for the third and final section. Members of
the third section are called "Lazybones." 
     The entire ceremony and ritual is carried on in a
comparatively quiet and orderly manner. Once, in the time of the
famous Hillel, there was such a surge and crowding at the
sacrifice of the Pesach that an old man was crushed to death, but
that never happened again. So orderly is the crowd that all three
sections have finished in less than two hours, and the priests
are left alone to clean up the court.

(At the crucifixion of Christ with darkness coming from about
noon to His final death, the Temple curtain being split in two
that divided the holy place from the most holy place, there would
have been so much fear and confusion in the Temple, it is not
possible what you have read above, would have been administered.
And besides that, the books of Moses carry no such instructions
as needed in the Tabernacle or Temple as pertaining to the
Passover slaying. For it is clear from the books of Moses that
the individual groups could slay and eat the Passover, without
any priest being involved. No "out of the norm" ritual service
was needed in the Temple apart from that which was
designated by the laws of Moses, certainly the slaying of the
Passover lambs DID NOT have to be done in the Temple - Keith
Hunt) 

Towards Evening

     Thousands of Jews rush from the Mount of the Temple through
the streets of Jerusalem, each bearing on his shoulder the
sacrificial animal wrapped in its own skin. All are busy and
expectant, preparing themselves for the great night of the year,
the night of redemption. Darkness descends on the holy city.
Everywhere sheep and goats, spitted on fragrant pomegranate wood,
are roasting in the clay stoves which stand in the courtyards of
the homes. These stoves are called "Pesach-ovens" and are
movable; should there be heavy rain they are carried into the
house. The groups are now gathering. Relatives and friends
assemble from near and from far.
     Every large room is a meetingplace for a group. Nobody is
omitted. The poor are invited to the homes of the rich and a
spirit of brotherliness, of national unity, binds all together at
the feast. All are partners: masters and slaves, men and women,
the aged and youthful. All are dressed in white, festive clothes,
much adorned and bedecked. The women, especially, wear jewelry in
honor of the occasion. The Babylonian women are easily
differentiated from the native women, since they wear brilliantly
colored garments; the Palestinian women, however, wear only
clothes made of bleached linen.
     The celebration begins. All is quiet in the streets. The
full moon moves over the flat roofs of Jerusalem and bedecks
every thing in silver. In the homes people lounge on sofas 
placed around the room. The left hand rests on soft cushions, the
right hand takes food and drink from small, individual tables set
before each feaster. One sits at the head of the room and leads
in the ceremonial observance. First a glass of wine mixed with
water is taken. Then the right hand and is washed and all
partake of lettuce dipped in a tart liquid. Then the sacrificial
animal is served and is eaten with matsoh and bitter herbs,
dipped in charoses, a mixture of ground nuts and fruits in
wine. Then begins the second part of the ceremonial of the
evening; the reciting of the story of the festival, and the
discussion of the ceremonies that go with it. A second glass of
diluted wine is drunk and the son of the household asks why this
night is different from all other nights. His father answers him
with excerpts from the Bible telling about the deliverance from
Egypt and then explains the meaning of the sacrificial lamb, the
matsoh, and the bitter herbs. All listen to him with great
attention and devotion. And when he starts to sing Hallel, they
all join in loudly. They conclude with the benediction for
redemption and are filled with the hope of immediate deliverance
from their enemies and the removal of the foreign governor and
his foreign soldiers from the holy city.
     It is now quite late in the night. The third and fourth
glasses of wine have been finished and the feast, with its atten-
ant ceremonies, is over. The older members of the group, however,
still recline on their sofas and relate and interpret the story
of the Exodus. Here and there a member of the group nods, or
falls fast asleep. Some of the younger element would like to
celebrate further, but their elders restrain them. After eating
the sacrificial animal, no entertainment is allowed, such as is
common after ordinary feasts. The feasters must satisfy
themselves with going from one group to another, greeting and
hailing friends. Once more the streets of Jerusalem are filled
with promenading Jews, natives and pilgrims side by side. Many of
them are on their way to the Mount of the Temple, for the Levites
now open the gates of the Holy House and Jews spend the rest of
the night there, praying and singing hymns of praise to God.
……………………………….

Such was the observance of the Passover as the Pharisees had
formed it over the centuries after the Jews came forth from the
Babylon captivity. Many things had been added and adopted, the
two worst being the added Temple slaying of the Passover lambs,
and secondly, even more incorrect, the Passover being on the 15th
day and not the 14th, hence the blending of the Passover meal
with the first holy day of the feast of Unleavened Bread, which
then blended what was originally TWO feasts, making up 8 days in
total, into a Feast of 7 days. Truly the words of Christ in Mark
7 about "traditions" making void the commandments of God, come to
clear view in the Pharisee teaching on how and when to observe
the Passover - Keith Hunt

To be continued


#11 

Christ in the Passover 

The Modern Seder

                   
by Ceil and Moishe Rosen (1978)


THE MODERN SEDER

(Jesus came from the tribe of Judah; He was Jewish; although you
could say Christianity came from Judah, it is not true that
Christianity came from "Judaism" for a New Covenant came into
being with Christ, and that New Testament set another new way to
remember and observe the Passover. Christianity moved into its
own life and form; it left behind the old. Those trying to find
"Jewish Roots" or involved in "Messianic Judaism" and going back
to various Jewish traditions, many of them the traditions of the
Pharisees that made void the commandments of God, and are going
backwards. Christianity moved out from under the canopy of
Judaism, it moved forward, setting its own path and a different
way of life. It's not wrong to remember your nation and culture
from whence you came, but Christianity is like as the apostle
Paul said, knowing his background in the nation of Judah, and his
Pharisee theology: "But what things were gain to me, those I
counted loss for Christ. Yes, doubtless, and I count all things
but loss for the excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus my
Lord: for whom I have suffered the loss of all things, and do
count them but dung, that I may win Christ" [Philippians 3:7-8]. 
Yet, for your interest I have reproduced this chapter of this
book. It shows you how the Jews are locked into the old Passover
[with added rituals] for not accepting Christ Jesus as the
Messiah. One day, they will see their Messiah coming in glory,
they will see He was the Christ of 2,000 years ago, and they will
then move into the New Testament life and the Passover of the New
Covenant - Keith Hunt)

 
THE MODERN SEDER

     In Jewish homes, the lighting of the holiday candles
separates the sacred from the mundane, the Sabbath of rest from
the week's cares. Tonight the blue white flames cast a halo of
light over the holiday table, inspiring a sense of holiness. They
lend a soft patina to the silver service, and their flickering
glow is mirrored in the eyes of the seated company. Savory aromas
from the kitchen mingle with the scent of the hot wax, the grapy
smell of the wine, and the acrid fumes of freshly ground
horseradish. An air of festivity reigns, tempered by solemn
anticipation.
     The father or grandfather of the family conducts the
Passover seder. For this special occasion, the leader of the
feast is wearing a long, white outer garment of cotton or silk
called a "kitel." The kitel is worn by Orthodox Jewish men at
Passover and a few other special times. It is also a burial
garment. 1  This wide-sleeved ceremonial robe is a symbol of
purity, reminiscent of Temple times when no one could participate
in the sacrifices unless he was in a state of Levitical purity.
It also reminds us of the white robe of the high priest and of
the robe of righteousness that God has promised to give to His
elect (Isaiah 61:10; Revelation 6:11; 7:9). On his head, the
leader of the feast wears a tall, white, silk head covering
shaped like a crown, portraying
......

1 See "Kitel," Encyclopaedia Judaica, 10:364.
......


that on Passover night a man is king and religious leader over
his own household. 1
     All eyes now turn expectantly to the leader as he stands and
opens his Haggadah. He raises his wine glass for all to see and
chants the kiddush, the prayer of sanctification that ushers in
all Sabbath days and most of the Jewish holidays. This blessing
expresses thanksgiving to God for choosing Israel and for giving
feasts and holidays to His people. Tonight a special blessing is
added for the commandment to commemorate the redemption from
Egypt. The most widely recognized portion of this prayer is:
"Blessed art thou, Lord our God, King of the Universe, Creator of
the fruit of the vine." Upon the close of this benediction,
everyone at the table sips from the first cup of wine, called the
cup of sanctification. This cup of sanctification consecrates the
ritual meal.
     Next the hostess brings in a small towel and a silver bowl
filled with water. This ceremonial washbasin contains only about
a cup of water. The leader dips his fingertips into the bowl and
dries them with the towel in preparation for handling the food.
He picks up the "karpas" (celery, parsley, or lettuce) from the
seder plate and hands a small portion to each participant.
Everyone recites together: "Blessed art thou, Lord God, King of
the Universe, who createst the fruit of the earth." And everyone
dips the greens into salt water and eats. At ancient Greek and
Roman banquets, this was the traditional beginning for a formal
meal. This Hellenistic culture influenced Jewish custom and
practices during the formative stages of stand-
......

1 Jewish men wear a small head covering (yarmulke) when they
pray. The miter described above is usually reserved for the
cantor who leads the synagogue worship. At Passover the host, as
religious leader of the evening, may wear the miter.
......


ardizing the seder. Contemporary thought endows the ritual with
added symbolism: the greens represent life, which is often
immersed in tears, represented by the salt water. The host now
turns his attention to the unity, the three wafers of unleavened
bread. He bypasses the top wafer, takes out the middle wafer, and
breaks it in half. He puts one of the halves back into the unity.
Then he wraps the remaining piece of this middle matzo in a white
napkin or puts it into a special, white, silk bag. While the
children cover their eyes, he hides or "buries" that portion of
the middle matzo, usually beneath one of the pillows or under the
tablecloth. This buried or hidden wafer of unleavened bread now
has a name, "aphikomen." We will see the aphikomen later in the
Passover service.

     The ritual that follows is very old. We know this because
the prayer is in Aramaic, the language used in the land of
Israel, mainly during the time of the second Temple. To this day
it is read in Aramaic, not Hebrew. The host uncovers the
unleavened bread again, holds up the plate, and everyone recites:
"This is the Bread of Affliction which our ancestors ate in the
land of Egypt. Let all who are hungry come and eat. Let all who
are in need come and celebrate Passover." Then they include
phrases that must have been added after the destruction of the
Temple: "This year we are here: next year in the land of Israel!
This year we are slaves: next year free men!" Here again, as with
the cup set out for Elijah, we see the Messianic hope expressed.
Although we are free from Egyptian slavery, we are slaves. When
the Lord brings us back to Zion in the days of the Messiah, we
will be truly redeemed, truly free!

(Jesus is the way, the truth and the life. It was He who said,
"The truth shall set you free!" But the Jews today are not free,
for they will not acknowledge the truth, so they live in the
past, while still looking for the Messiah to come - Keith Hunt)

     Now the wine glasses are refilled, and the youngest child at
the table asks the traditional four questions:

Why is this night different from all other nights? On all other
nights we can eat bread or matzo. Why, tonight, only matzo?
On all other nights, we can eat any kind of herbs. Why, tonight,
bitter herbs? On all other nights we don't dip herbs we eat into
anything. Why, tonight, do we dip twice? On all other nights we
can eat either sitting up straight or reclining. Why, tonight, do
we all recline?

     The last question about reclining is a relatively late
addition to the original questions. It may have been added as a
replacement for the question referring to the Paschal lamb, which
was asked while the Temple and the sacrifices remained: "Why do
we eat only meat which is roasted?"

     The father or grandfather replies with the prescribed answer
in the Haggadah, taken from Deuteronomy 6:21 and 26:8: "We were
Pharaoh's bondmen in Egypt; and the LORD our God brought us out
thereof with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm." From this
introductory statement proceeds the reading of the whole epic of
redemption from the Haggadah. The Mishnah describes this answer
as "beginning with shame and ending with glory" (Pesahim 10:4).
The narrative combines Bible history and rabbinical commentary.
It includes God's calling Abram out of idolatry, the hardships of
the Hebrews in the land of Egypt, the punishment of the
Egyptians, the dividing of the Red Sea, the giving of the
Sabbath, and the giving of the Law. The climax is the recital of
the ten plagues that God poured out on the Egyptians. With the
mention of each plague, everyone dips or pours out one drop of
wine from his wine goblet into a small saucer. This saucer, not
the goblet, is known as the cup. When the saucer is filled with
the ten drops of wine, it is called the cup of iniquity, a term
symbolic of God's judgments. Now is posed the rhetorical
question: "Is it for this [the judgments] that we praise God?"
The answer follows: "No, for God loved the Egyptians even as He
loved us. But it is for God's infinite mercies that we praise
Him."
     This sets the stage for a happy song recounting the numerous
acts of love and mercy that God bestowed upon Israel. The name of
the song is one Hebrew word, "dayenu," meaning, "it would have
been sufficient." At the end of every line of the song comes the
one-word refrain, "Dayenu," sung about ten times with much gaiety
and handclapping. The song ends with the spoken words:

"Then how much more, doubled and re-doubled, is the claim the
Omnipresent has upon our thankfulness! For He did take us out of
Egypt and execute judgments ... and justice ... [did] tear the
sea apart for us ... satisfy our needs in the desert ... give us
the Sabbath [and] ... the Torah [Law] ... bring us into the land
of Israel, and build us the House of His choosing to atone for
all our sins."

     Now, in obedience to the ancient admonition of Rabbi
Gamaliel, the host makes special mention of the three crucial
ingredients of the Passover: the Passover sacrifice (symbolized
by the shank bone on the seder plate), the bitter herbs, and the
unleavened bread (matzo). He explains each item, holding up the
bitter herbs and matzo. However, he does not lift up the shank
bone, lest what is only the symbol of the Passover lamb be given
the significance of a real sacrifice, which is forbidden. Then he
adds these words:

"In every generation let each man look on himself as if he came
forth out of Egypt. As it is said: 'And thou shalt tell thy son
... it is because of what the Lord did for me when I came forth
out of Egypt'"[see Exodus 13:8].

     This text is based on the teaching of the Mishnah (Pesahim
10:5) that the Exodus and redemption are not to be taken only as
history; each Jew is to consider the experience as personal.
(Even so, those of us who are spiritually redeemed by Jesus, the
true Passover Lamb, see Him as being sacrificed for each of us,
individually and personally, although the actual event happened
two thousand years ago.)

(The Jews believe they are the children of God as much as any
Christian believes they are. Their theology teaches they can be
saved WITHOUT Christ; the Christian therology teaches there is
only ONE through whom you can be saved - Christ Jesus - Acts 4:12
- Keith Hunt)

     Now the company raises the wine glasses in a toast of
thanksgiving to the goodness of God and proclaims: "Let us then
recite before Him a new song: Hallelujah!" They put the glasses
down without drinking and recite Psalms 113 and 114, the first
portion of the Hallel, which literally means "praise." Then they
raise the wine glasses once again, repeating the ancient prayer
of Rabbi Akiba, probably written just after the destruction of
the Temple.

"Blessed art thou, O Lord ... who redeemed us ... and has brought
us to this night ... So, O Lord ... bring us to other festivals
... happy in the building of thy city ... And there may we eat of
the sacrifices and the paschal offerings, whose blood will come
unto the walls of thy altar for acceptance. Then shall we give
thanks to thee with a new song, for our redemption and the
liberation of our soul. Blessed art thou, O Lord, Redeemer of
Israel. Blessed art thou ... Creator of the fruit of the vine."

     This is the signal for drinking the second cup of wine,
called the "cup of praise."
     Following the drinking of the second cup, they pass
around the basin of water. Everyone repeats the special prayer
for ceremonial handwashing and washes his hands. The head of the
feast now breaks off pieces of unleavened bread and distributes
them to all at the table. They recite together the prayers of
thanksgiving for bread and for the commandment to eat unleavened
bread; they eat a morsel of the matzo.
     Next the host dips some of the bitter herb into the sweet
charoseth mixture and offers a piece to each participant. Before
eating it, they pronounce another benediction, thanking God for
commanding the eating of bitter herbs. The resultant tears
produced by this ceremony are a fitting memorial to the hardships
of our ancestors!
     The host goes on to make a sandwich of bitter herbs and
unleavened bread. He eats it, saying:

"In memory of the Temple, according to the custom of Hillel. Thus
did [Rabbi] Hillel when the Holy Temple still stood: he used to
combine unleavened bread and bitter herbs and eat them together,
to fulfill that which is said: 'They shall eat it with unleavened
bread and bitter herbs.'"

     By this time, the younger children are a bit droopy-eyed
from the warmth of the room, the sips of wine, and the hypnotic
flickering of the candles. The older people are not drowsy; they
have just been jolted into alertness by the mouthful of
horseradish. But now the hostess sets aside the seder plate and
disappears into the kitchen, and this is the real cue for
everyone to come to life. Here come the good things that have
been teasing their nostrils all day!

     The Passover meal is literally a banquet. It usually begins
with the traditional hard-boiled eggs dipped or flavored with
salt water. Then come the appetizers. In Ashkenazi homes (those
of northern and eastern European culture), two of the favorite
appetizers are chopped liver, similar to the French liver pate,
and gefilte fish. The latter is similar to Scandinavian fish
balls without the sauce. Jewish people like to use horseradish
instead, even when it is not Passover. Then, almost always, there
is a matzo ball soup, a rich, clear chicken broth accompanied by
fluffy, featherlight dumplings made of finely ground matzo and
many well-beaten eggs. The main course is usually a stuffed,
roasted fowl, or beef of some kind. Jewish people today
traditionally do not eat lamb on Passover, because there is no
Temple and no Passover sacrifice. But those of us who are Jewish
believers in the Messiah Jesus feel that it is fitting and
meaningful to eat lamb at our Passover meals in remembrance of
the One who came to be the Lamb, whose sacrifice overshadows the
sacrifices of all the lambs slain in the Temple (Hebrews 9).

(Let me say here, there is nothing in the New Testament
Scriptures to forbid you eating lamb at any meal during the 7 day
Feast of Unleavened Bread. The Passover evening, correctly being
the beginning of the 14th day of the first month, Nisan or Abib,
is NOT A MEAL! Hence lamb will not be eaten during that specific
service, for it is not a meal under the New Testament ordinance -
all fully explained in my many studies of the Passover - Keith
Hunt)

     There are many more good things to eat, like salads and
vegetables, limited only by the cook's imagination and
resourcefulness. For dessert there are dried fruits, nuts,
specially baked Passover cookies, sponge cakes, and coconut
macaroons, all made without leaven; and imported marzipan and
other candies from Israel.

(Remmeber all this is going on during the first evening hours of
the 15th day, which is technically the first holy day of the
Feast of Unleavened Bread. This is the practice handed down from
the Pharisee Jews - Keith Hunt)

     Jewish people of Eastern and Mediterranean descent
(Sephardim) have different favorite foods, in keeping with their
own culture and tradition. Their cuisine often includes tomatoes,
eggplant, and fruits like dates, figs, and oranges, which are
native to their countries. The only foods never to be found on
any Passover table, besides bread or other types of leaven, are
pork and shellfish. These are forbidden at all times by Leviticus
11 and Deuteronomy 14 to those Jewish people who are still under
the Law. 

(The authors are Christian Jews and so they believe such laws of
clean and unclean foods are abolished, and only none-Christian
religious Jews need to obey them - nothing could be further from
the truth - Keith Hunt)

     With dinner at an end, the dessert dishes are cleared
away, but the Passover seder is far from finished. Something is
missing - the "aphikomen"! The name aphikomen comes from the
Greek "epikomios," meaning "after dinner revelry," or "that which
comes last." In ancient times, this was apt to be rather rowdy.
Since that type of behavior was totally unsuitable for a
religious celebration, the rabbis of old substituted a solemn
commemoration of the Paschal lamb. In Temple times, the lamb was
the last thing to be eaten; now, in the absence of the
sacrificial lamb, the unleavened bread was to represent the
Passover sacrifice. The taste of the matzo and the memory of the
lamb were to linger in the consciousness of each celebrant.
The children search now for the missiing aphikomen, making a
little game of it. The adults call out advice as the children
search the room: "You're way off base!" "You're cold." "You're
getting warmer!" Soon someone finds it and turns it over to the
head of the feast with a triumphant grin of anticipation, for he
knows that he will receive a reward for it - a small gift or sum
of money.

     The gaiety and boisterousness of the search give way to
solemnity as the ritual of the seder continues. The host unwraps
the "aphikomen" and distributes olive-sized pieces to everyone. 1
All partake of it with quiet reverence. In Western culture, there
is no blessing or word spoken. But in the Sephardic or Eastern
tradition, they say: "In memory of the Passover, sacrifice, eaten
after one is sated." Nowhere do they add the prophetic words of
Jesus at the Last Supper: "This is my body which is given for
you" (Luke 22:19).
     After this, no one may have any more food or drink at the
seder other than the third and fourth cups of wine. At
......

1 By rabbinic tradition, an olive-sized morsel is the smallest
over which one can say a blessing.
......


this point many Haggadahs include the recital of Psalm 126, one
of the Songs of Ascent.

     Now that the meal is officially concluded by the eating of
the aphikomen, the ritual portion of the seder continues with the
recitation of the final table grace. At Jewish meals there is a
berachah (short prayer of thanks) for each food as it comes to
the table, but the main table grace always comes after the meal.
At the seder, the host now pours the third cup of wine before
this prayer. Then he stands and repeats the traditional words in
Hebrew: "Gentlemen, let us recite the blessing." The seated
company responds: "May the name of the Lord be blessed from now
unto eternitv." The host continues: "Let us bless Him of whose
food we have eaten." Then the participants read a lengthy prayer
of thanksgiving. Toward the end of this table grace, we hear
again the expression of hope in God's final deliverance in the
days of the Messiah.

"Take pity, O Lord ... on Israel ... on Zion the habitation of
thy glory and on the kingdom of the House of David, thine
anointed ... may there rise and come ... the remembrance of us...
and our fathers, and the remembrance of the Messiah the son of
David, thy servant ... and Jerusalem thy holy city ... and all
thy people, the House of Israel ... on this festival ... The
Compassionate One - may He send Elijah the prophet (may he be
remembered for good) to us that he may bring us good tidings of
salvations and consolations.

(Oh indeed God will send someone who will come in the "spirit and
power" of Elijah before the day of the Lord, as the prophets and
Jesus have said, but the Jews will not recognize him, for he will
come in the name of the Messiah Christ - Keith Hunt)

     If Passover falls on a Friday night (the beginning of the
Sabbath) they also add the following:

"The Compassionate One - may He cause us to inherit that day
which is all Sabbath and repose, in the everlasting life. The
Compassionate One - may He find us worthy of the days of the
Messiah and of the life of the world to come."

(You see how they pray that they will find everlasting life and
the world to come. They pray for this while they ignore or reject
the One who can give them eternal life. The are blinded, the vast
majority in Israel are blinded as Paul shows in Romans 9 through
11. The day will come when that blindness will be removed - then
they will find salvation and the world to come, but until that
time, they must wait and rest [in death, if dead before Jesus the
Messiah comes in glory] until their resurrection day - Keith
Hunt)

     This speaks of that ultimate Sabbath of rest about which
Paul is writing in Hebrews 4:9.

     Immediately following that prayer, the host leads again in
the blessing over the wine, and everyone drinks the third cup,
commemorating the verse in Exodus 6:6b: "I will redeem you with a
stretched out arm." This third cup is the cup of redemption, also
at times called the cup of blessing. It is the cup of redemption
because, say the ancient commentaries, it represents the blood of
the Paschal lamb. Some Haggadahs call it the cup of Elijah
because it directly follows the prayer for the coming of Elijah.
Another reason for that title may be because of what happens
next.
     The children have been watching Elijah's cup at the foot of
the table. In some households, the cup was filled at the
beginning of the seder; in others, it is filled now. They squint
hard at the dark red contents of the cup. Will Elijah come and
drink from the cup? Maybe he is here now, only he is invisible.
Did he take a sip? It looks like there is just a little less wine
than there was a while ago! Alas, if that is true, it is only due
to evaporation. But maybe he is still going to come! Wait and
see, but now we must go on with the service.

(They look for the Elijah to come, and he will, in the form of a
man, as like John the baptist was Elijah in his day [Mat. 17],
but not knowing Christ or the New Testament Scriptures, they will
look for him in vain. But then again the huge majority of
Christians will not know the Elijah to come before the day of the
Lord, for He will speak the word of truth, which they are blinded
from. Only the very elect will recognize the Elijah to come, and
the restitution of truth - Keith Hunt)

     Jewish scholars think the prayer that comes next, "Pour out
Thy Wrath," originated during the Middle Ages when Jews were
severely persecuted for the faith, especially at Passover time.
This prayer is not found in the earliest editions of the
Haggadah. It calls for God's judgment on the heathen, and it
sounds rather harsh. But taken in context with the other prayers
given above for the coming of Elijah, it fits into the pattern of
thought: "May God send the Messiah, heralded by the prophet
Elijah, to vanquish all our enemies and set up His Kingdom of
peace."

(The Jews pray for the still coming of the Messiah, while they
cannot see that He already came in the form of Jesus Christ, two
thousand years ago. Yet the Messiah will come and the Jews will
in that day recognize Him as the prophet Zechariah tells us in
chapters 12 and 13. See my expounding of that prophetic book on
this Website - Keith Hunt)

     The leader now sends one of the children to open the door to
see if Elijah is coming in answer to the prayers. The words are
not prescribed until later in the Haggadah reading, but just as
the door is being opened, everyone usually exclaims: "Blessed is
he who cometh in the name of the Lord" The youngsters are
round-eyed with awe as the door slowly creaks open. A gust of
cool night air sweeps into the room but no one is there. Oh well,
maybe next year. The child closes the door and comes back to the
table.

     Next the host leads in the recitation of the second portion
of the Hallel, Psalms 115 to 118. These verses are the same as
those of Temple times. They lead into the Great Hallel, which is
Psalm 136. In this well-known psalm, the Levitical choir in the
Temple sang out the praises of Jehovah and the great events of
Israel's history. At the end of each phrase or line, the
congregation responded, "For His kindness endureth forever!"
The earliest commentaries (Pesahim 10:7 of the Mishnah) record a
"Benediction of Song" after the Hallel. The Talmud, which is a
commentary on the Mishnah, teaches in Berakbot 59b that one of
these benedictions was the Great Hallel and another was at least
some part of a hymn called "The Breath of Every Living Thing."
     This closing hymn before the fourth and final cup of wine is
again a prayer of praise and thanksgiving. It begins: "The breath
of every living thing shall bless Thy Name," and ends: "Blessed
art thou, 0 Lord, God and King, who art mightily praised, God of
thanksgivings, Lord of wonders, who chooses song and psalm, King,
God, the life of the world." Once again, everyone at the table
lifts his wine glass and chants the blessing over wine. Everyone
drinks from the fourth cup. This last cup of the Passover seder
commemorates the verse in Exodus 6:7: "And I will take you to me
for a people."

     One of the modern versions of the Haggadah 1  comments very
aptly on the fourth cup and the verse it commemorates: "The
redemption is not yet complete. The Fourth Cup recalls us to our
covenant with the Eternal One, to the tasks that still await us
as a people called to the service of God, to a great purpose for
which the people of Israel live."
     The editors of that particular Haggadah see the purpose of
Israel as being "The preservation and affirmation of hope." But
we, who are familiar with the promises and prophecies of
Scripture, see a greater purpose for Israel that of one day
proclaiming to the whole world that the Messiah is, indeed,
Saviour and King!

     Because of the words, "I will take you to be my people,"
some call this fourth cup the cup of acceptance. Others prefer to
call it the cup of Elijah. There is merit to both titles, for
Elijah will yet come to herald the redemption that will be
complete only when Israel fulfills God's entire plan; that is,
when Israel recognizes and proclaims the Messiah (Zechariah
12:10), she will truly be the people of God, as foretold in
Jeremiah 32:38-40.

     And now, at last, with the drinking of the fourth cup, the
seder is drawing to a close. Happy songs and festivity often
continue afterward late into the night, but the service
......

1 Herbert Bronstein, ed., "The New Union Haggadah," rev. ed., p.
91.
......


officially ends with one last prayer for the rebuilding of
Jerusalem:

Concluded is the Passover seder,
According to its law and custom. 
As we have lived to celebrate it, 
so may we live to celebrate it again. 
Pure One, who dwells in his habitation 
Redress the countless congregation. 
Speedily lead the offshoots of thy stock 
Redeemed, to Zion in joyous song. 
NEXT YEAR IN JERUSALEM! 1
......


1 Jewish people already living in Israel say instead: "Next year
in Jerusalem rebuilt!"
......

                       .............................


Note:

So it is that the Jews without Christ in the Passover, live in
the past, praying for the prophet Elijah to come and reveal good
news to them. He will come and he will reveal good news to them
and all the world, but most will never know he came and restored
all things, they will blindly go their way, tripping over the
truth, picking themselves up, dusting themselves off, and walking
on as if never seeing it. Then will come the end of this age,
then will come the Messiah, then the blindness will be lifted
from all faces, then the world will see who the Elijah was, and
who the Christ Messiah is. Then the covering cast over all faces
will be lifted, light of truth will pour into their minds, and
all people will finally rejoice as the knowledge of God will
cover this earth as the waters cover the sea beds. Then all will
know Christ in the Passover.

Keith Hunt

February 2010

 



 



 

 


No comments:

Post a Comment