Friday, October 16, 2020

PROPHECY---- AMOS WARNS YOU!

 PROPHETS  OF  OLD  FOR  TODAY!




Amos For Today


Chapters 1 to 6

                              

Amos gave his prophecy about the time of 760 B.C. 

He was from the southern kingdom of Judah. He was 

a shepherd. He was shocked at the moral decline in the 

kingdom to the north - Israel. But it was all written 

down for the prophecy is also for the very end time

of this age. Leading up to the return of the Messiah

Christ Jesus.


The Old Testament prophetic books can only be 

understood when you know who Israel and Judah 

are today.  The House of Israel never returned from

the Assyrian captivity— they migrated North and 

West, eventually becoming the Western Nations, all but

Germany [who are the peoples of the Assyrian Empire].

The Protestant prophets will not see this hence they 

have no truth about end time prophecy; they are 

blind leaders of the blind.



CHAPTER 1


Amos starts where Joel left off. God will ROAR FROM ZION AND 

UTTER HIS VOICE FROM JERUSALEM. Amos gives prophecies 

of punishment to Damascus, Gaza and Tyrus, Edom and Ammon.


     We have covered those prophecies in the three so-called

major prophetic books of Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel. The

obvious reading here is a context for the THEN PRESENT in 

the days of the time of Amos. But as with a lot of prophecy to

nations, it has an application in the end times.



CHAPTER 2


     The prophecy against Moab or the Jordan area people is given

in verses 12-3. We have covered this in the three major prophet

books.


     Now Amos turns to prophecy against Judah and in the MAIN

against the house of Israel. Judah has forsaken God and they have

despised the LAW of the Lord; they have NOT kept His

commandments; their lies cause them to err.  A fire will come

upon them. Let me state it once more, the Jews in the main, and

especially those in the Holy Land are a SECULAR people, only 

a SMALL minority of them are at all religious, and they are

religious to the Old Testament, as the vast majority of them DO

NOT accept Christ Jesus as the Messiah  If you are watching the

TV news you will see the corruptions of government that ever 

seem to plague the state of Israel. The troubles, the war, the 

fighting  "fire" as Amos calls it is ever present with the Jews in 

the Holy Land.


Prophecy to Israel


     Israel, you peoples of North-West Europe, the British

nations, and the United States of America; you have sold the

righteous for silver, and the poor for a pair of shoes. In other

words the righteousness of God is of little value to you. You

have cast the Lord out of your daily living, your wickedness,

crime, evil, corruptions in high places, and your immorality 

(as like a father and son going into the same young lady the 

way  Amos put it) is all too common. Your sexual immorality 

is  beyond words to describe it, it is so common a place.


     God relates how he destroyed the Amorites who were as tall

as the height of cedars and strong like an oak tree. The Lord is

saying that Israel better not look to any of its might or power

of war machines, for to God they are as nothing. It is HE who is

the GIANT, and He can destroy whoever He wills.


     The Eternal wants you to remember it was He that brought

your fathers up out of the land of Egypt, and gave you the right

wholesome laws. You on the other hand told your children and

everyone, "Oh, do not speak God's word to us, do not tell us what

He is saying or going to do." God is heavily burdened by your

sins, hence He has determine that the flight will perish from the

swift, the strong will not strengthen his force, nor the mighty

deliver themselves. Those that handle the war machines will not

stand or deliver themselves. The day will come when those who

claim to be courageous among the mighty will run away naked

(verses 6-16).


CHAPTER 3


     HEAR THIS God says to the whole family of Israel that came

up out of Egypt. It is you only that God chose of all the families 

of the earth. You shall suffer for your sins. God says it was I and 

you, but can two walk together unless they agree.

     Israel you walk no more in the pathway of the Lord; the Lord

walks on a different road than you do. It is not possible to walk

together.

     If the trumpet is blown in the city, if the war bell sounds,

shall not the people be afraid? You bet they will be! So it shall

be. Shall destruction come upon your cities and it is not the

Lord who has done it? 

     As for the natural disasters that come on your towns and

cities, as you have been experiencing in the last number of

years, it may well be coming directly from God; certainly the

Lord is ALLOWING it to come on you, but you will still not 

TURN to Him in humble repentance.


"SURELY THE LORD GOD WILL DO NOTHING, 

BUT HE REVEALS HIS SECRETS UNTO HIS SERVANTS 

THE PROPHETS!!" (verses 6-7).


     THIS WEBSITE IN PART IS DEVOTED TO BLOWING 

THE TRUMPET, TO BEING A WATCHMAN TO THE HOUSE 

OF ISRAEL AND JUDAH. WHETHER YOU WILL LISTEN 

OR NOT, YOU ARE BEING TOLD WHAT WILL COME 

UPON YOU FOR YOUR INIQUITIES AND SINS!


     God says you know NOT to do the RIGHT, YOU STORE UP 

VIOLENCE, so violence will come on you. An enemy is coming 

to take your strength and destroy your cities. When God comes to 

visit your transgressions with punishment the false religions of Baal 

will be dashed to the ground. All the winter houses and summer 

houses that are rich with physical wealth will be wiped away. There 

will be no more the hugely rich mansions of film-stars and the rich

elite of your nations. They like all will be dashed to pieces.


CHAPTER 4


     The days will come, the time will arrive when God will take

you away like with hooks and your prosperity with fishhooks.


     Already God has given you cleanness of teeth in many of your

cities, troubles and disasters have come, but you still will NOT

return to the Lord your God. At times the rain has been held back

from you, it rained on one town and not on another, drought was

here and there. Some cities had to have help from other cities,

but still you have NOT returned to your God.

     The Eternal has smitten you with blasting and mildew, the

various insects have eaten your crops, and your harvests have

suffered, BUT STILL YOU WILL NOT TURN TO YOUR GOD. 


     THE ALMIGHTY HAS SENT AMONG YOU THE PLAGUE 

AND THE PESTILENCE, YOU HAVE DECEASES YOU CANNOT 

HEAL. THE ETERNAL HAS ALLOWED YOUR YOUNG PEOPLE 

TO BE STAIN BY THE SWORD, AND YOU ARE FACING WARS 

THAT YOU CANNOT WIN. THERE IS DEATH AND STINK IN 

YOUR NOSTRILS, BUT YOU STILL WILL NOT TURN TO SERVE 

YOUR GOD IN SPIRIT AND IN TRUTH!!


     THE LORD SAYS HE HAS OVERTHROWN SOME OF YOUR 

TOWNS AND CITIES AS HE OVERTHREW SODOM AND 

GOMORAH - COMPLETELY WIPED OFF THE FACE OF THE 

EARTH ..... BUT YOU STILL HAVE NOT TURNED TO HIM!!


"THEREFORE THUS I WILL DO UNTO YOU, O ISRAEL: 

AND BECAUSE I WILL CONTINUE TO DO IT TO YOU, 

THEN YOU HAD BETTER BE PREPARED TO MEET 

YOUR GOD!!" 

(verses 1-12).


     Who is it that you are dealing with Israel? Have you forgotten? 

Are you so blinded you do not understand WHY this is happening 

and  WHO is sending and allowing all this disaster to strike you?


     LISTEN! This is He who you are contending with!


"For, lo, He that FORMS THE MOUNTAINS AND CREATED 

THE WIND,  and declares unto man what is his thoughts, that 

MAKETH  THE MORNING DARKNESS, and treads upon the high 

places of the earth, THE LORD, THE GOD OF HOSTS IS HIS NAME!" 

(verse 13).


     The Eternal God of CREATION controls all. I do not know which of the 

natural disasters come DIRECTLY from God, BUT SOME OF THEM DO! 

And certainly the others that have bombarded you have been ALLOWED 

of God. He has many times WITHHELD HIS PROTECTIVE HAND 

FROM YOU, BUT YOUR STIFF NECK WILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO 

HUMBLY REPENT AND TURN AWAY FROM YOUR SINS. 


CHAPTER 5


     HEAR this from the Lord O house of Israel. The city that went out 

by a THOUSAND shall leave but a HUNDRED, and that which went 

forth by a HUNDRED shall leave but TEN!


     God calls out to you to SEEK Him and LIVE! If not He will then 

break out on you as like fire. You need to SEEK HIM who rules the 

physical creation and the whole universe.


     What else does your Lord have against you Israel? You HATE

those who REBUKE you; you ABHOR him that speaks 

UPRIGHTLY to you, that tells it like it is, who names your sins and 

lays the cards on the table. You have your plans to increase and increase 

and build and build, plant and plant. But your sins, the sins of the

rich over the poor (as we have seen in the Wall Street crash of

September 2008) .... you know them, and so you had better be

prudent and KEEP SILENT, FOR THE EVIL TIME FOR YOU IS 

GOING TO COME!


[MAYBE THIS COVID VIRUS IS JUST THE START OF THE 

WESTERN NATIONS [THE HOUSE OF ISRAEL] FALL AND

EVENTUAL DESTRUCTION]


     Once more God cries out to you to SEEK GOOD, and not evil,

that you may LIVE! You need to HATE evil, and LOVE the good, 

and establish true JUDGMENT in your gates. Then if you do, the Lord

may be gracious unto you. As we have seen in Ezekiel if the sinner 

turns from his sins and does righteousness, he shall LIVE IN HIS 

RIGHTEOUSNESS, HE SHALL NOT DIE!


     Sadly your turning back to the pathway of the Lord will not

come about. Therefore you WILL WAIL in the streets, on the

highways, in the fields, when the Lord passes through your lands

to punish you.


     WOE to those who desire the DAY OF THE LORD. Yes many want

to see Christ back on earth, but they do not stop and think, or

are taught false doctrines like the "rapture" - they do not realize that 

BEFORE Christ can come back, there is to be the DAY OF THE LORD. 

And that day is DARKNESS, and NOT light. We have seen this in 

the book of Joel. It will be a day as when a man flees from a lion, 

and a bear meets him .... just NO WAY OUT OF THE KILLING AND 

THE BLOOD!

     The DAY OF THE LORD will indeed be DARKNESS! (verses 1-20).


     

Religious Abominations of Israel


     God says He HATES your religious festivals and the days you

have chosen. He will not be a part of them. He IS NOT a part of

them. He will NOT ACCEPT the sound of your religious songs and

the nicety-nice spiritual music you play. You can do the outward

practices of religion, your calling on His name, your prayers,

your spiritual sounding talk and sermons and all of it, BUT HE

WILL NOT ACCEPT IT, HE IS NOT A PART OF IT, YOU HOLD 

TO THE TRADITIONS OF MEN WHILE IGNORING THE 

COMMANDMENTS OF GOD. As Jesus said in the Gospels 

IT IS ALL IN VAIN DO YOU WORSHIP GOD!! 

     The Lord is NOT A PART of your FALSE religion and FALSE

festivals, such as SUNDAY, EASTER, CHRISTMAS,  NEW YEAR, 

HALLOWEEN, and even THANKSGIVING DAY, many more 

that this or that church organization traditionally hold. They are 

indeed traditions of men and do not come from the  truth of the Bible.


     You will NOT TURN in truth to the Lord Almighty so you will

in His good time go into captivity for all your abominations and

sins (verses 21-27). 


CHAPTER 6


     WOE to those in Zion and who put their trust in Israel Samaria. 

The Jews of the Holy Land do indeed put trust in the nations of Britain 

and the United States. There will be no lasting security in such a close 

connection of loyalty.

     

     YOU PUT AWAY FROM YOURSELVES THE IDEA OR THE 

THOUGHT THAT EVIL WILL COME UPON YOU, AND THAT 

VIOLENT DESTRUCTION CAN BE YOUR REWARD. YOU LIE 

UPON BEDS OF IVORY, YOU EAT AND BE MERRY, YOU 

WALLOW IN YOUR PHYSICAL RICHES, YOU DRINK YOUR 

WINE, YOU DRESS YOURSELVES IN FINE LINEN AND 

OILS AND JEWELS. BUT YOU ARE NOT GRIEVED FOR THE 

BREACH (margin) OF ISRAEL. YOU DO NOT LOOK AT YOUR 

SINS AND WICKEDNESS. 


     THE LORD SAYS HE ABHORS THE EXCELLENCY OF JACOB, 

HE HATES YOUR PALACES OF WEALTH. HE WILL DELIVER 

IT ALL UP TO DESTRUCTION. ALL SMALL OR GREAT WILL 

FIND DEATH, FEW WILL BE LEFT.


     GOD WILL RAISE UP A NATION TO COME AGAINST ISRAEL, 

THEY WILL AFFLICT YOU, THERE WILL BE NO ESCAPE! 

(verses 1-14).


     I have shown you in many studies that it will be the nation Empire 

of Germany Europe, the last Holy Roman Empire to rise in Europe. 

Nay it is already there in Europe. It just needs more time to FORM 

AND BUILD, which it will. When God is ready, when He says this 

age must come to a close, that Jesus must be sent back to bring the

Kingdom of God to earth, then all the end time prophecies will

come to pass. And the DESTRUCTION of Britain/America by the 

Beast power of Europe is the beginning of the Great Tribulation on 

this earth. Then the DAY OF THE LORD and finally the RETURN 

of Christ Jesus.


                            ...................


To be continued



Amos For Today


Chapters 7 to 9

                            


CHAPTER 7

The plumbline is upon Israel, the straight edge, the recognizing 

of wrong, of sin, will not be winked at; God will not pass by with 

a blind eye any more; the time for judgment and punishment will 

come; Israel will be laid waste, the sword will come upon all the 

lands of Israel.

     Yes, this section was written as the historical events of the days 

of Amos, Jeroboam the king was to die. Amos is told to "get lost" - 

get back to Judah and give prophecy there but not in Israel. 

     Amos replies that he was going about his work as a herdsman

and gatherer of sycamore fruit; it was the Lord who called him

and told him to go and give warning prophecy to Israel. Amos

continued his reply by telling them that the SWORD of death and

destruction would come on them. The people of Israel would go

into captivity into another land.

     And we know of course that it DID HAPPEN. We have seen also

in Jeremiah 30 that these things will HAPPEN AGAIN, AT THE 

END TIME. The house of Israel and House of Judah are still two

Separate peoples when Christ comes again. They are in a state of 

Destruction and captivity to their enemy lovers.  The nations of the

House of  Israel are today the nations of the Western world, all but 

Germany. The House of Judah are the Jews. You will ALL  FALL

IN CAPTIVITY TO THE BEAST/BABYLON HOLY ROMAN 

EMPIRE LED BY GERMANY AT THE END TIME. ONLY ONE

TENTH OF YOU SHALL BE ALIVE AT JESUS’ COMING TO

DELIVER YOU OUT OF  THAT DESTRUCTION.


CHAPTER 8


     God once more tells us that He will not pass by with closed

eyes. The summer fruit is over, the day of reckoning is at hand

for Israel. The songs in the temples of Israel, the religious

institutions, will be songs of HOWLING; for dead people will be

everywhere, there will be silence in Israel (verses 1-2).


Judgment against Deceitful Merchants


"Hear this, O you that swallow up the needy, even to make the

poor of the land to fail" (verse 4).


     What have we seen in September 2008? We have seen the greedy

"I'll get my riches" investor bankers of Wall Street CRASH as

their sinful ways FAILED, and the average "fellow on the street"

is also made to fail. Then the most un-popular President since

Richard Nixon, George Bush, wants the average citizen to bail out

the filthy-rich elite of Wall Street. It is a DOUBLE WHAMY for

the average USA citizen. Those investors had the attitude of

"When will the new month day be gone, that we may sell corn? And

the Sabbath, that we may set forth wheat, making the ephah small,

and the shekel great, and FALSIFYING the balance sheet by

DECEIT!" (verses 5).


     It is the attitude of "To hell with you and everything, do

not stop for this day or that day, work at the deception all the

time. I will do anything to make myself rich." Have you seen the

various number of mansions these people have here and there, as

it was shown on the TV news programs. And there was all the

extremely expensive "parties" these guys put on to help falsify

the balance sheets. At the moment there is no talk about making

these fellows PAY BACK MILLIONS, or making them sell their 

huge expensive homes, cars, boats etc.

     It was the attitude of "We may buy the poor for silver, and

the needy for a pair of shoes; Yes, sell the refuse of the wheat!"

(verse 6).


[YOU ARE SLOWLY BEING EATEN AWAY WITH NATURAL 

DISASTERS, AND NOW THIS COVID-19 VIRUS; MANY

SAY WE SHOULD JUST IGNORE IT AND GO ABOUT

OUR DAILY LIFE AS BEFORE. WITH THAT ATTITUDE YOU

WILL BE BROUGHT TO MISERY AND DEATH]


     Time may pass, the USA may BAIL these guys out, maybe it

will take a TRILLION dollars of tax money to stay off even more

failure. Maybe the USA will get out of this MESS from the deceit

and serious mistakes of white collar bankers ... maybe it will

all be history one day, but God says "I have SWORN by the

excellency of Jacob, Surely I will NEVER FORGET ANY OF 

THEIR WORKS" (verse 7).


     For this "falsifying the balanced by deceit" and all the

other iniquities of Israel, God says, "Shall not the land TREMBLE

for this, and every one MOURN that dwells therein; and it shall

rise up wholly as a flood; and it shall be cast out and drowned,

as by the flood of Egypt" (verse 8).


     As sure as the rising of the sun, the day of punishment is

coming on Israel for their totality of sins.



The Day of Mourning for Spiritual Famine


     Today we have the great blessing of FREEDOM to study the

Word of God. You can open your Bible in the lands of Israel any

time, at your discretion and study the words of God. You can

listen to the radio, watch and listen to TV, and all the religious 

programs you like. You can get on the Internet and open up my 

Website and my Blog, study the word of the Lord to your 

hearts content.


     But it is not always going to be this way!!


     There is coming a time when the sun will go down at noon,

and God will darken the earth in the clear day. The day is coming

when the Feasts of Israel, all the ones that give you joy, shall

be held with MOURNING; your songs will be songs of 

LAMENTATION; sackcloth will be the garment to wear, and baldness 

upon every head; it will be as the mourning of an only son who dies, 

and the day will be as bitterness.


     A FAMINE IS COMING! Not a famine of bread to eat, nor of

thirst for water, [though that is coming also] BUT A HEARING THE 

WORDS OF THE LORD!  (verse 9-11).


     THE TIME WILL COME WHEN THIS WEBSITE WILL NOT BE 

AVAILABLE TO YOU! WHEN OTHER WEBSITES OF MY 

CO-WORKERS WILL NOT BE AVAILABLE TO YOU! THE TRUTHS 

OF THE BIBLE WILL NOT BE PROCLAIMED TO YOU AS THEY 

CAN BE TODAY! 

     IF GOD IS GIVING YOU THE OPPORTUNITY TO STUDY 

FROM THIS WEBSITE YOU BETTER USE THE TIME YOU ARE 

GIVEN NOW, FOR THE DAY COMES WHEN AN OPEN, STRAIGHT 

TALKING AND INDEPTH WEBSITE LIKE MINE WILL NOT BE 

ALLOWED. THE LAST END TIME BEAST POWER, THE

BABYLON MYSTERY RELIGION CHURCH, WILL THROW 

THIS AND SIMILAR WEBSITES TO THE DUST. IT WILL BE 

GONE, THERE WILL COME A TIME, RELATIVELY SHORT YES, 

BUT A TIME NEVER-THE-LESS OF NOT HEARING THE TRUE 

WORDS OF THE LORD.


     FOR THE TIME WILL COME WHEN "they (the people of Israel and

Judah) shall wander from sea to sea, and from the north even to

the east, they shall run to and fro to SEEK the WORD  of the Lord, 

AND SHALL NOT FIND IT!!" (verse 12).


     The young virgin ladies and men shall faint for thirst -

spiritual thirst for sure. All who put their trust in the false

religions of Samaria Israel shall FALL in that day (verse 13,14).


     It will be the time of Jacob's Trouble as Jeremiah put it in

his prophecy (Jer. 30: 7-9). The time of great tribulation on earth

as never the like before nor ever will be again (see Daniel 12:1-

3; Mat.24:21). IT IS THE GREAT TRIBULATION THAT 

LEADS TO THE DAY OF THE LORD! THE LAST YEAR OF

THIS AGE


CHAPTER 9


Vision of God Destroying the Religious Idolaters


     The vision that Amos sees is towards all the false religion

in Israel. The words are chilling to say the least. When it is

time to punish the house of Israel (which is most of the Western

world) the individuals that have not come under the Babylon

Mystery religion of the European Beast power will suffer in no

uncertain way; as the book of Revelation shows, if you have not

taken the "mark" of the Beast you will be hunted down and killed

as also shown in this passage of Amos. For many there will be no

escape, fleeing will not save you, going down into the ground,

climbing the hills to heaven, out or under the sea; all a

figurative way of saying ...."And though they go into captivity

before their enemies, thence will I command the sword, and it

shall slay them: and I will set mine eyes upon them for evil, and

not for good" (verses 1-4).


     As the 12th chapter of Revelation shows, there will be SOME

from the very TRUE Church of God, that will find protection in

the WILDERNESS. Satan and his Babylon Beast will try to find

them, but God will use the natural elements like the earth-quake

to defend and protect the saints in the wilderness.

     The "rapture" of these saints to heaven (as a good portion

of fundamental Christianity teaches) is a FALSE doctrine. But

Revelation 12 does teach that SOME true Christians will be

PROTECTED on this earth in the WILDERNESS.

There are studies on this Website explaining all this.


     God is the CREATOR, it is He who has power over the forces

of nature (verses 5-7).

     His eyes are on the SINFUL kingdom, and He will destroy it

off the earth, but in so saying, He also adds He will NOT UTTERLY

destroy the house of Jacob (verse 8).


"For lo, I will command, and I will sift the house of Israel

among the nations, like as corn is sifted in a sieve, yet shall

not the least grain fall upon the earth. All the sinners of my

people shall die by the sword, which say, 'The evil shall not

overtake nor prevent us'" (verses 9-10).


     It is an attitude of UN-REPENTANCE! As we have seen only 

ONE in TEN shall live. Those left shall not be lost or fall to the

ground. During the Great Tribulation those Israelites left alive

will start to REPENT! They will see why they have been destroyed

and punished with death and sorrow. They will begin to turn back

to their God in spirit and in truth. By the time we get to the

"day of the Lord" 12 THOUSAND from each tribe of Israel will 

have God's Spirit in them (Revelation 7) except the tribe of Dan - 

and I do not know why Dan is not included, we are not told.


     Then the time will come when God will raise up the

tabernacle of David that is fallen, the breaches will be closed

up; Israel will begin to rise from ruin, for Jesus the Messiah,

as we have seen in so many prophecies already, will COME, and

will GATHER the scattered children of Israel and Judah from the

lands of their enemies and bring them back to the Holy Land. 

True religion - the tabernacle of David (as it is written - the man

after God's own heart) will be RESTORED to Israel, as Christ and

the resurrected saints with Him come to Jerusalem, to dwell in

Zion.

     As we have seen, and as we will in the book of Obadiah,

Israel will possess Edom (Turkey) - deal out punishment on them

as the Israelites march back from Europe and enter Turkey on

their way to the Holy Land (verse 12).


     It is the time for the NEW AGE to begin! The Kingdom of God

is on earth. So the Lord says:


"Behold, the days come, says the Lord, that the plowman shall

overtake the reaper, and the treader of grapes him that soweth

seed; and the mountains shall drop sweet wine, and the hills

shall melt.  And I will BRING AGAIN the captivity of my people 

of Israel, and they shall build the waste cities, and inhabit them; 

and they shall plant vineyards, and drink the wine thereof; they shall

also make gardens, and eat the fruit of them. And I will plant them 

upon their land, and they shall NO MORE be pulled up out of their 

land which I have given them, says the Lord thy God" (verses 13-15).



     This could NOT be a prophecy for the Israel or Judah of

Amos's day, and Judah's return from Babylon after their 70 year

captivity, FOR THE JEWS WERE AGAIN REMOVED FROM 

THE HOLY LAND under the Roman Empire. They did not become 

a nation again in the Holy Land until 1948 A.D.



     The whole CONTEXT and the whole messages in all the other

prophetic books of the Old Testament,  even THEIR CONTEXTS, 

prove the verses here in Amos, ARE FOR THE VERY TIME OF THE 

END AND THE SETTING UP OF THE KINGDOM OF GOD ON

EARTH, WHEN JESUS WILL RETURN AND DELIVER ISRAEL 

AND JUDAH OUT OF CAPTIVITY AND PLANT THEM BACK 

IN THE HOLY LAND, WHERE THEY WILL BE PROSPEROUS 

AND ALL OF THEM WILL HAVE THE SPIRIT OF GOD, AND

WILL FINALLY BE A LIGHT TO THE WORLD, AS WAS 

ORIGINALLY INTENDED BY THE LORD (Deuteronomy 4).


     GOD SPEED THAT DAY!!!


                          .......................


Entered on my Website September 2008


No comments:

Post a Comment