Christians and Wine? #4
What the Bible says
INSTRUCTIONS FOR CHOOSING SERVANTS The letters Paul wrote to Timothy have become known as Pastoral Epistles, because they contain information for Pastors that, "....you may know how you ought to behave yourself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God.." (1 Tim. 3:15 ). Among the many instructions these letters contain is the qualifications for DEACONS or those that will be appointed to serve in an official way within the church. Notice 1 Tim.3:8 "Likewise must the deacons be grave, not doubletongued, not given to MUCH wine..." The NIV translates, "....not indulging in much wine..." The Fenton translation is "...nor addicted to much wine..." The Modern Language also renders it the same as Fenton. The Living Bible says,"They must not be heavy drinkers..." The Amplified Bible is as the KJV. The literal Greek reads, "not to much wine." For the Greek word 'much' the ENGLISHMAN'S GREEK CONCORDANCE gives among other words these: abundant, great, long, much, plenteous, great deal. The ANALYTICAL GREEK LEXICON gives: great in magnitude or quantity, much, large, the many, the mass, greatly, vehemently. This Greek word is used dozens of times in the NT - some of the passages where it is found are: Mt.6:30; 13:5; Mk.12:41; Lk.7:11; 12:19,48; John 3:23; 6:10; Acts 10:2; 15:7; Rom.16:6; James 5:16; Rev.19:1. It is obvious the word means - plenteous, great deal, mass, much or great in quantity. Now are we to suppose that what Paul was laying down to Timothy for the qualifications to deaconship was that a man must not drink much grape juice? What if he did drink a great deal of unfermented grape juice - would that disqualify him from becoming a deacon? What if he drank very little grape juice but drank prodigious amounts of orange juice - would that be okay and so qualify for deaconship? I will say with Paul "I speak as a fool." Surely no person is going to say that Paul was here teaching Timothy that a deacon could not drink much unfermented grape juice!! It should be plain to see that Paul was referring to alcoholic wine. He was telling Timothy that a man who is being considered for the office of deacon can not be someone who is given to drinking much, plenteous, a great quantity of wine as a practicing way of life. Paul is not saying that he can not drink fermented wine PERIOD! The very structure and use of the Greek word 'much' should make that truth plain to the unbiased mind. If Paul had wanted to teach Timothy that no servant of the Lord should ever drink alcoholic wine, he could have easily said and used the greek words "not to wine" or "shall not drink wine" or some other emphatic phrase. The truth is Paul was being inspired by the Holy Spirit to write these words "not given to much wine." There is no way around it - neither the OT or the NT, neither Moses or Jesus or Paul or any other inspired writer of the Bible ever condemned anyone for drinking fermented beverages. What they did condemn was lusting after such drinks, being deceived by such drinks and getting drunk or tarrying long at them and becoming an alcoholic. VARIOUS QUESTIONS ANSWERED ALCOHOLISM It is often pointed out by such individuals as Mr.Saunders (which he does in his booklet) that NO ONE is immune to alcoholism. I would answer that with the ungenerated heart no one is immune to, lying, stealing, profanity, hate, covetousness, sexual lust and immorality and under the right (or should I say wrong) circumstances, even murder. All of these are SINS just as alcoholism is. Should we not talk because we may lie? Should we not look at a man or woman because we are not immune to lust? Shall we not pick up and use a knife because some have become murderers with such a tool? Should we not get married because no one is immune (without God's grace and help) to divorce? There are many things in life that the Lord gives us to use (i.e. our sex drive) either for good or for evil. The thing itself is not always evil, but yes the Lord knows that in giving it to us - allowing us to use it - even saying at times we are to use it(such as marriage and reproduction) - He knows it may be used wrongly, to hurt ourselves and others. That's why He gives us MUCH instruction on the right use of the things He says we are allowed to do and handle in life. He knows that the ungenerated heart of man is prone to evil, that what the Lord intended to be a BLESSING for us, man would abuse, twist and pervert into EVIL . Does the Eternal come along and take away our mouth, eyes, sexual organs, marriage, childrearing, talents and inventive abilities because we often do not use them the correct way as He intended ? No, He does not. He cries out to us to come to Him, learn HOW to use the things He has given us to use CORRECTLY and for our BLESSING and right enjoyment. The Lord cries out to mankind to come and partake of His very divine NATURE - His POWER and LIFE so that man can have the STRENGTH and the self-control to be able to properly CONTROL all that He gives and allows us to use. One of the things the Lord allows us to use is alcoholic beverages! For individuals like Mr.E.L.Saunders to write and talk about having more of the Spirit of God and then in essence by what they say about this subject and those "sipping Christians" deny that the very Holy Spirit of Power can keep you from ever becoming an alcoholic, is to me, a denial of the Spirit they so earnestly want to preach. Let me say again, I have known and still know dozens of Spirit filled Christians who for many many years have been drinking fermented wine and other strong drink and are no nearer becoming alcoholics than this PC I'm using - I happen to be one of them. The POWER of the Holy Spirit is POWERFUL - it does give you the power and self-control to be temperate in all things. I have never been drunk in my entire life - no not once, and that credit goes to the Lord not me and His Spirit that He has so freely given me. To those who may be alcoholics let me say this. You can, with the wonderful help from the Spirit of God, and good organizations like the AA, OVERCOME!! It is also true that in many cases many such individuals may have to stay away from alcohol completely, although I have know some who were able to be moderate drinkers. The Lord does not command you to drink alcohol - it is not a sin to be a teetotaller. MODERATION In the booklet "Should Christians Drink Fermented Wine?" by Pastor Saunders he says on page 27, ".. Mr.Rowe says,'The Key to Christian drinking is moderation.' Of course he dare not tell us what 'moderation' means...But let me ask this question, How is one to make known to all men what 'moderation' is in consuming alcoholic wine? Who 'draws the line' and where? As a Pastor and Shepherd of the flock of God, am I to tell the people that one glass of wine is 'moderation' or is it two glasses, or perhaps more?" Now Mr.Rowe in his article did not legislate what 'moderation' is. Neither do I legislate moderation. Why? Very simple - the Lord does not legislate moderation! This is what the Lord God legislates: "..be not addicted to wine ..." (Barclay) or be not "one who sits long at his wine" (Earle - Word Meanings in the NT) 1 Tim.3:3. ".....not given to much wine......" 1 Tim.3:8, "Be not drunk with wine...." Eph.5:18. The Eternal teaches us we can eat clean meat if we desire - He does not legislate how much! The Lord taught that a Christian would pray - He did not legislate how many minutes a day. Jesus said a Christian would fast - He did not legislate how many times a year! Our heavenly Father says His children can wear Jewelry and Make-up (though some will argue that also) if they desire (if you have never had that proved to you then study my studies on this Website) but He does not legislate how much! I could go on with other examples, but I hope you see the point. Within the bounds of what God has said is lawful for us a Christian is to use the Spirit of God, which is the very nature of God (2 Pet.1:4 the divine power (chap. 1:3), to let the mind of Christ be in them so they are growing up in Him unto a mature and perfect man (Eph.4:13-15 ). This is the development of RIGHTEOUS GODLY CHARACTER The Lord does not have hundreds of do's and don'ts that He has legislated for us on keeping the Sabbath - He has given us a few broad principles only, and then expects us to use His Spirit of sound-mindedness and wisdom to handle all the many circumstances and questions that may arise on Sabbath keeping. Ministers should be on the whole more spiritually mature than those they are serving, but to think that they must legislate things to their congregations that not even the Lord has legislated is not only becoming as the Pharisees of Jesus' day, but worse still it is setting oneself up as God Himself. Woe unto those ministers who want to dictate what color of tie, shoes, blouse, suit etc. their people should wear to services or how long the men's side-burns should be or the ladies dresses. Woe unto those ministers who want to dictate how many pieces of jewelry the women should or should not wear. Woe unto those ministers who want to legislate how many hours of T.V. a week their members are to watch. Such ministers are no longer "a help of your joy" but have become religious legislating dictators. Some seem to want God or their minister to legislate every act of their lives - some ministers seem to want to legislate every act of those they pastor, when to come in, when to go out, how many glasses of apple juice to drink, what time to go to bed etc. They perhaps feel some kind of safety in this - no decisions to make, no personal responsibility, no having to go to the Lord for His help and guidance under different and specific situations. This may seem the neat and clean way to do things, "Oh if only the Lord would legislate for me what moderate drinking is, then I would not have to make all these mental judgments" is what some desire, but God's way is not to have us as robots. Sure He gives us some rules that are cut and dry, such as "You shall not steal" but often it is the broad outline He gives and we are to use His spirit and wisdom to stay within the bounds - and that develops CHARACTER! As for alcoholic beverages, the one boundary line is, you MAY or you MAY NOT drink such beverages, and the other boundary line is, do not sit long, get ADDICTED or get DRUNK on wine. The Christian is to stay within that boundary, and that is moderation! IS DRINKING ALCOHOL HABIT FORMING? Mr.Saunders writes on page 17 of his booklet,"Consuming alcoholic beverages whether it's wine, liquor, or just 'coke' is habit forming..." This statement is totally incorrect! To say "Consuming alcoholic drinks MAY be habit forming" is one thing, but saying "Consuming alcoholic beverages IS habit forming" is altogether another. How do I know that Mr.Saunders' statement is wrong? I know from the experience of a person as close to me as you can get - myself. I at times, such as when observing the seven day Feast of Tabernacles, may consume anywhere from one to four alcoholic drinks per day, some weekly Sabbath days I may enjoy 1 or 3 glasses of wine, BUT THEN a number of weeks may go by without drinking any fermented beverage. Drinking wine or any alcoholic beverage is only habit forming if you let it be! DON'T LOOK ON WINE? In answer to my statement that there is no direct command of the Lord that we should not drink alcoholic beverages, some will say yes there is, and turn quickly to Prov.23:31 "Look not thou upon the wine when it is red, when it gives its color in the cup. ..." and declare, "There you are, if we are not even to look upon wine how much more are we not to drink it." Some say this statement is very EMPHATIC and emphasize the word emphatic. The comment in the WYCLIFFE BIBLE COMMENTARY is an example of this teaching. If we are to be EMPHATIC with the first part of this clause should we not be as willing to be just as emphatic with the last part? " Look not thou upon wine WHEN IT IS RED..." So it is only RED wine that we are emphatically told not to look at - WHITE wine and STRONG DRINK (shekar) are excluded!! Oh the silly reasonings of men that desire to uphold their personal emotional whims and are not willing to let the word of God correct them so they maybe, "not unwise but understanding what the will of the LORD is" (Eph.5:17). Look at the CONTEXT of Prov.23:31. Verse 30 says, "They that tarry long at wine ..." Verse 32, At the last it bites like a serpent..." ADAM CLARKE was being honest with this verse when he wrote in his commentary: "Let neither the color, the odour, the sparkling, etc., of the wine, when poured out, induce you to drink it. However good and pure it may be, it will be to THEE a snare, because THOU ART addicted to it, and hast NO SELF-COMMAND." (emphasis mine). The context shows: clearly that this proverbial advice was given to those "that tarry long at wine" to those who are addicted to it. They should not be tempted to drink it when its poured out - they had better stay away from it altogether because they will get drunk, and when awake will seek it yet again (verses 33-35). This is instruction is for those who are addicted to alcoholic beverages. STRONG DRINK - HARD LIQUOR It is very important to note that when you relate the words "strong drink" (Heb. is 'shekar') as used in the Bible, you do not think of this as meaning what we today call 'hard liquor.' It may refer to a type of 'beer' that the ancients used, but it should not be acquainted with our hard drinks like 'gin' or 'brandy.' As for the health benefits of our hard liquors, see my next comments. ALCOHOL AND ITS EFFECTS ON HEALTH In trying to drive the nail home for the case of 'total abstinence' Mr.Saunders quotes a Doctor Haven Emerson as saying, "Alcohol is a ... protoplasmic poison ... causes disease .... causes death from acute and chronic poisoning ... decreases expectancy of life ..." Here is my answer to this argument. FIRST. The word 'alcohol' is a very broad term, applied to all fermented intoxicating beverages from mild wines to beer to hard liquor. There is enough data available to show that a prolonged and regular use of our modern HARD LIQUORS is detrimental to ones health. Their usefulness may be seen in the famous stories of the snowy Alpines, where the St.Bernard dogs were sent out to rescue lost or trapped people in the snow. They would carry a little bottle of brandy around their necks which would often make the difference between life or death for the stranded But on the whole, hard drinks should be used very sparingly and not in any way as a regular diet or your health could be adversely effected. SECONDLY. As shocking as this may sound to many, Doctors and Researchers are often to say the least, very BIASED and to say the worst - plain LIARS! They will often twist the facts or give you half truths to comply with what they want you to believe because of their personal views on that particular subject. You don't believe me? You want proof of this statement of mine? I will give it to you from the pen of a well known and respected doctor - DR. ROBERT S. MENDELSOHN, Chairman of the Medical Licensing Committee of the State of Illinois (who is now dead as I put this study up to my Website. I wrote this study in 1985). "Doctors have been shown not to be above fudging and even fabricating research results when the stakes were high enough. Dr.Leroy Wolins, a psychologist at Iowa State University, had a student write to thirty-seven authors of scientific reports asking for the raw data on which they based their conclusions. Of the thirty-two who replied, twenty-one said their data either had been lost or accidentally destroyed. Dr.Wolins analyzed seven sets of the data that did come in and found errors in three significant enough to invalidate what had been passed off as scientific fact." (Confessions of a Medical Heretic, pages 205 and 206). It should also be remembered that Doctors disagree among themselves on various subjects as much as the Theologians do on what the word of God teaches. You should handle the statements of Doctors as you should Theologians - get ALL the facts from various sources, PROVE all things as Paul wrote and then hold fast to that which is good! THIRDLY. Whatever case can be brought against the use of HARD LIQUOR on a prolonged basis, such can not be brought against WINE. It has now been proved beyond a reasonable doubt that wine is GOOD FOR YOU!! FOURTHLY. As the LORD has instructed in His word that we can if we desire, partake of fermented wine and Biblical 'strong drink' I know that it must be under normal conditions, HEALTHY for you! The Eternal God would not give us positive instructions relating to anything if it was "that alcohol(or something else I will add)in any form should never be introduced into the human body" as E.L.Saunders writes (page 46 of his booklet). The Lord God was the creator of man, He knows what is good for man to take into his body to promote health - He is the one who gave the clean and unclean food laws, not some doctor in his clinic or research lab. Why I have read articles by doctors who claim pork, horse meat or crabs are good for you, listing the amount of protein, vitamins and minerals in each. The Eternal says such is not good for you - they should not be consumed, but some learned doctors think otherwise. The Eternal says wine and strong drink you may consume, but some educated doctors say it is 'poison.' Such have rejected the revealed revelation of God and have as Paul wrote, "Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools" (Rom. 1:22). We are admonished to AVOID science when it is in direct contradiction to the revelation of God, "...avoiding profane and vain babblings and opposition of science falsely so called: Which some professing have erred concerning the faith..." (1 Tim.6:20,21). THE PRESERVATION OF GRAPE JUICE? I have not chosen to enter this area of contention, as to whether the ancients knew how to preserve grape juice unfermented, because it has no bearing on proving or not whether it is Christian to drink alcoholic beverages. WINE IS GOOD FOR YOU ! For more information you may want to purchase the book: GATEWAY TO WINE AND HEALTH by Herbert M.Baus. Obtainable from Cole's Book Stores or from Deborah Bond, 4 Ireland Court, Islington, Ont. M9A2C9. Phone (416) 233-9407. (I'm not sure if that book is still in print in this year of 2003 - Keith Hunt). .............. TO BE CONTINUED |
No comments:
Post a Comment